Jon Buchholdt v. Jeremy Nelson and Erin Gonzales-Powell
Cases that cite this one
4 later published cases cite this decision.
- Raymond Katchatag v. State of Alaska, Department of Corrections (Alaska 2026)
- Landon Rector v. Ammie Parker, F/K/A Ammie Rector (Alaska 2025)
- Jett M. Million v. Diane L. Hubert (Alaska 2026)
- Kimberly Wallace Goodwin, individually and as the natural parent of Jackson Wallace Goodwin and Jonathon Goodwin, individually and as the parent of Jackson Wallace Goodwin v. Mat-Su Midwifery, Inc., Judi Davidson, and Darcy Lucey, Mat-Su Midwifery, Inc., Judi Davidson, and Darcy Lucey v. Kimberly Wallace Goodwin, Individually and as the Natural Parent of Jackson Wallace Goodwin and Jonathon Goodwin, Individually and as the Parent of Jackson Wallace Goodwin (Alaska 2024)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion
Notice: This opinion is subject to correction before publication in the PACIFIC REPORTER. Readers are requested to bring errors to the attention of the Clerk of the Appellate Courts, 303 K Street, Anchorage, Alaska 99501, phone (907) 264-0608, fax (907) 264-0878, email [email protected].
THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF ALASKA JON BUCHHOLDT, )
) Supreme Court No. S-18341
Appellant, )
) Superior Court No. 3AN-18-06395 CI v. )
) OPINION JEREMY NELSON and ERIN R. ) GONZALEZ-POWELL, ) No. 7669 – August 18, 2023
)
Appellees. )
) Appeal from the Superior Court of the State of Alaska, Third Judicial District, Anchorage, Una S. Gandbhir, Judge.
Appearances: Dylan C. Buchholdt, Anchorage, for Appellant. Darryl L. Thompson, Darryl L. Thompson, P.C., Anchorage, for Appellee Jeremy Nelson. No appearance by Appellee Erin Gonzalez-Powell.
Before: Winfree, Chief Justice, Maassen, Carney, Borghesan, and Henderson, Justices.
CARNEY, Justice.
INTRODUCTION
A self-represented litigant was awarded $200,000 in judgments against his former attorneys. One of the attorneys, who had not appeared in the litigation, filed a motion to set aside the judgment and, when that was denied, a motion for reconsideration. The superior court denied both motions and the attorney appeals, arguing he was never properly served and the superior court therefore lacked personal jurisdiction over him. We conclude that he did not meet his burden of establishing that the judgment was void. We therefore affirm the denial of his motions.
FACTS AND PROCEEDINGS A. Facts
In January 2018 Jeremy Nelson sued his former attorneys, Jon Buchholdt and Erin Gonzalez-Powell, alleging legal malpractice. In June Nelson, who was incarcerated and representing himself, sent the summons and complaint by certified, restricted mail to Buchholdt’s law office. The filings were rerouted to Buchholdt’s home and the receipt was signed by “Suz Miller,” who Nelson alleges was Buchholdt’s paralegal. The return receipt indicated that Miller was Buchholdt’s “agent.” Other documents relating to the lawsuit, including cross-filings from Gonzalez-Powell, were apparently delivered by hand or in person. In August the court issued a Notice of Dismissal for Failure to Serve. In September Nelson filed an affidavit and attached the return receipt. In April 2019 Buchholdt filed for bankruptcy in federal court and listed Nelson’s lawsuit — by its case number — as a contingent liability.
B. Proceedings
The superior court held two days of trial in 2020, one in February and the other in July. Nelson participated by telephone from jail each day; Gonzalez-Powell appeared on only the first day; Buchholdt never appeared. In September 2020 the superior court found in favor of Nelson, noting that Buchholdt “never filed an Answer to either Complaint, failed to appear for any of the procedural matters listed . . . and otherwise failed to defend . . . despite the Court’s many attempts to solicit a response after multiple notices.” In April 2021 the superior court awarded Nelson $100,000 in damages from each defendant.
Two months later Buchholdt filed a motion for relief from judgment based on Alaska Civil Rule 60(b)(4), arguing that the judgment against him was void because he was never properly served. Buchholdt stated in his affidavit that he “had no reason to believe that [he] was a named defendant or party in [the] plaintiff’s lawsuit.” Nelson opposed the motion, and the court denied it in December 2021. Buchholdt filed a motion for reconsideration making the same argument.1 Nelson again opposed and the court denied reconsideration in January 2022.
Buchholdt appeals, arguing that the superior court erred because he was never properly served.2
STANDARD OF REVIEW
We apply our independent judgment to the denial of a motion for relief under Rule 60(b)(4) because “the validity of a judgment is strictly a question of law.”3 Questions of personal jurisdiction are also legal questions to which we apply our independent judgment.4 When reviewing legal questions, “[w]e ‘adopt the rule of law that is most persuasive in light of precedent, reason, and policy.’ ”5
The denial of a motion for reconsideration under Alaska Civil Rule 77(k) is reviewed for abuse of discretion.6 “The abuse of discretion standard asks ‘whether the reasons for the exercise of discretion are clearly untenable or unreasonable’ and fall outside the boundaries of reasonable responses.”7 Our review “does not focus on the merits of the underlying decision, but only on the propriety of the denial of reconsideration.”8
DISCUSSION
Rule 60(b)(4) allows a party to move for relief from a judgment if the judgment is void.9 Judgments can be void for a number of reasons, including a lack of personal jurisdiction resulting from improper service of process.10 Buchholdt argues that he was not properly served by mail because he never personally signed for the service. He claims that the superior court therefore lacked personal jurisdiction and its judgment is void. Nelson argues that he properly served Buchholdt because a self- described agent signed for the summons and complaint. Nelson also argues that the judgment should not be voided because Buchholdt apparently received actual notice and then misled the court about it.
“[T]he burden of establishing a basis for relief [under Rule 60(b)] falls on the party seeking it.”11 This includes “the burden of demonstrating want of jurisdiction.”12 Buchholdt alleges that jurisdiction was improper, but he did not meet
Buchholdt asserts on appeal that he “did not have an agent who was authorized by commission or law to receive personal service of a summons and complaint via restricted delivery to addressee on his behalf.” But Buchholdt, as the movant, had “the burden of proving his entitlement to relief” before the superior court.15 He did not, and an unsupported, unsworn assertion — made for the first time on appeal — is insufficient to show that the superior court committed legal error by denying his cited Aguchak in Beam, we did not cite that case’s rule placing the burden on movants. Id. at 367 n.2. That holding pre-dated Beam and remains the rule now.
Rule 60(b) motion or that it abused its discretion when it denied his motion for reconsideration.16
CONCLUSION
We AFFIRM the superior court’s denial of Buchholdt’s motions for relief and for reconsideration.17
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.