Norris v. State
Norris v. State
Opinion
First degree robbery; life without parole.
On March 28, 1980, Mrs. Maurice Dandy was working at Luther's Snack Bar, of which she was a co-owner, in Pratt City, Jefferson County, Alabama, when she was robbed at gunpoint of approximately one-hundred to one-hundred and fifty dollars. Dandy identified the appellant at trial as the black male who robbed her and described the gun he had as "silver and big." There were no other witnesses to the alleged robbery and the State rested after Dandy testified.
The appellant testified in his own behalf and denied committing the robbery. He stated that he was in California on the date of the robbery, he had been there since December, 1979, and he remained there until May 24, 1980, when he boarded an airplane for Atlanta. According to appellant, he arrived in Birmingham on May 25, 1980, and went that evening to Luther's Snack Bar where he bought a "hamburger and chili dog." Appellant testified that, prior to this visit, the "last time" he had been in the snack bar was in December, 1979.
During cross-examination he denied owning or having a pistol, but acknowledged that he owned "an antique pistol, a .22," which was still in California. He also acknowledged that he knew John Moore, but denied being in Moore's store on April 8, 1980.
The appellant admitted having five prior felony convictions. Three of these convictions, two for grand larceny and one for robbery, occurred in 1966, when he was approximately fifteen years of age, and resulted in sentences totalling twelve years. Further, it was shown that, subsequent to the robbery in the instant case, appellant was twice convicted of first degree robbery and sentenced to twenty years in one case and life without parole in the other.
After the appellant testified, the State called John Moore as a rebuttal witness. Moore testified that he had known appellant for approximately fourteen years and that the appellant came to his "confectionary" store around 8:00 or 8:30 on the morning of April 8, 1980. After talking to Moore some thirty-five minutes, appellant demanded Moore's car keys at gunpoint. Moore stated that the weapon used was a "nickel plated" pistol. According to Moore, he gave the appellant his car keys and appellant then left in his (Moore's) car.
The presentation of evidence concluded with Moore's testimony. The jury subsequently found appellant guilty of first degree robbery. Pursuant to Alabama's Habitual Felony Offender Act, §
The testimony appellant objects to was rebuttal evidence. The admission of rebuttal evidence is within the discretion of the trial judge. Crow v. State,
Appellant's 1966 convictions occurred more than five years before the effective date of the Youthful Offender Act, §§
Moreover, the granting of youthful offender status rests in the discretion of the trial court, Ala. Code §
The three felony convictions were admitted by appellant at trial. In addition, the State offered evidence of these convictions at the sentencing hearing and this evidence affirmatively showed that appellant was represented by counsel at the time of the convictions. In our judgment, the trial court properly considered the three prior felonies for enhancement purposes.
The judgment of conviction by the Jefferson Circuit Court is affirmed.
AFFIRMED.
All the Judges concur.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Jessie Norris v. State.
- Cited By
- 25 cases
- Status
- Published