Richardson v. Arrington
Richardson v. Arrington
Opinion
Movant appeals from denial of a Rule 60 (b) A.R.Civ.P. motion to set aside a default judgment for failure of proper service.
In September 1982 defendant moved for stay of enforcement of the judgment and for relief therefrom, charging lack of proper service. After hearing, the motions were denied.
The issue presented on appeal is whether the judgment is void for lack of proper service.
It is settled that failure of proper service under Rule 4, A.R.Civ.P., deprives the court of jurisdiction and renders judgment by default void. Whitfield v. Sanders,
Rule 4.2 provides the basis for and the method of service of process upon persons out of state if the relief sought is an in personam judgment. The rule requires either service by certified mail with restricted delivery and return receipt or delivery by a process server. Rule 4.2 (b), A.R.Civ.P. If the return receipt for certified mail shows failure of delivery, service may be completed by publication under Rule 4.3, A.R.Civ.P., after filing with the clerk an affidavit setting forth facts indicating the reasonable diligence utilized to ascertain the whereabouts of the party to be served. Rule 4.2(b)(1)(C).
Under Rule 4.3 (d)(1), if service by publication is made necessary because the defendant has avoided service, an affidavit must be made alleging that defendant avoids service and averring facts showing such avoidance.1 Failure to comply with the requirements of Rule 4.3 (d)(1) in the averments of the affidavit renders service by publication ineffective. Milesv. McClung,
The affidavit filed by plaintiff clearly fails to allege avoidance of service, nor does it aver facts showing such avoidance. Therefore the court erred in failing to grant the 60 (b) motion of defendant. Its judgment denying the motion is reversed. The case is remanded with direction that the judgment by default be set aside as void.
REVERSED AND REMANDED WITH DIRECTION.
BRADLEY and HOLMES, JJ., concur.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Joe Marvin Richardson v. Ora R. Arrington.
- Cited By
- 10 cases
- Status
- Published