ALABAMA DEPT. OF PENSIONS AND SEC. v. Johns
ALABAMA DEPT. OF PENSIONS AND SEC. v. Johns
Opinion
This is an adoption case.
On December 14, 1982, the juvenile court terminated the parental rights of the mother of the child, the father being unknown, and the child's legal guardianship was placed with the Department of Pensions and Security (DPS). Mrs. Johns is the maternal aunt of the child and she and her husband (the Johnses) filed their petition in the probate court on December 29, 1982, to adopt the child. Those proceedings were transferred to the juvenile court upon the Johnses' motion in March 1983. In its report DPS objected to and did not consent to the child's adoption by the Johnses. The consent of DPS is a jurisdictional requirement in this case unless their withholding of it was arbitrary or unreasonable. Matter ofRoberts,
A question of fact was presented to the juvenile court as to whether the consent of DPS was arbitrarily or unreasonably withheld. Sanders v. Department of Pensions and Security,
The record before us does not reveal that the Johnses met that burden for no evidence was presented by the Johnses upon that controversy. The only evidence which is included in the record on appeal is the report of DPS which contained no indication of an arbitrary decision on their part.
In the posture of the matter as disclosed by the record filed with us, it is necessary to return this matter to the juvenile court where the Johnses shall have the burden of proof that DPS acted arbitrarily or unreasonably in withholding its consent and where DPS shall have the opportunity to refute the allegations and proof in that regard. Matter of Roberts,
Accordingly, a writ of mandamus is provisionally granted subject to the matter at bar being disposed of by the juvenile court as outlined above. Pending those proceedings in the juvenile court, the interlocutory adoption order is vacated.Matter of Roberts,
The foregoing opinion was prepared by Retired Circuit Judge Edward N. Scruggs while serving on active duty status as a judge of this court under the provisions of §
WRIT PROVISIONALLY GRANTED.
All the Judges concur.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Alabama Department of Pensions and Security v. Ronald Gene Johns and Kathy Johns.
- Cited By
- 10 cases
- Status
- Published