Nicholson v. State
Nicholson v. State
Opinion
Willie E. Nicholson appeals from the judgment and order of the Circuit Court of Conecuh County revoking his probation.
On May 5, 1982, appellant was arrested for possession of marijuana in violation of §
After information was received from an informant, Deputy Sheriff William Gibson stopped a car driven by the appellant. Deputy Gibson testified that he asked the appellant who owned the car and that the appellant stated that he was the owner. At the hearing before the trial court, the appellant testified that "it was my car." The appellant was searched by the Deputy Sheriff and no marijuana was found on him. A bag of marijuana was found lying between the legs of a passenger in the front seat, Jimmy Lee Richardson. Richardson was arrested and charged with possession of marijuana. A passenger in the back seat was searched. No marijuana was found on him and he was not arrested.
Deputy Sheriff Gibson testified that he searched the automobile and "the ash tray was open." He further testified, ". . . and the ash tray was open and in the ash tray I found two roaches — two smoked marijuana cigarettes." He then placed the appellant under arrest for possession of marijuana. The appellant testified that he did not know that Jimmy Richardson had marijuana in the car. The appellant further testified as follows:
"Q. . . . Those marijuana cigarettes up there in the ash tray of the car, did you know about them?
"A. No, sir. To my knowledge, there wasn't none in there.
"Q. Do you smoke?
"A. No, sir."
Further testimony of Deputy Sheriff Gibson was as follows:
"Q. But you charged him [appellant] there as he was the driver of the automobile.
"A. Yes, sir, he was the driver."
Jimmy Richardson, the passenger in the front seat of appellant's car, testified that he pled guilty to possession of marijuana. He testified that he took breaks from his work during the day, went to appellant's car and smoked marijuana and placed the cigarettes in the ash tray. He was unable to say how many breaks he took or how many cigarettes he smoked in appellant's car. He further testified that any marijuana found in the car was his and that the appellant "didn't know about it."
In the case of Free v. State,
Considering the entire record, we find no merit in the appellant's contention that the fact that the Order of Probation was not formally offered in evidence renders the revocation order defective.
In Armstrong v. State,
"It is not to be understood that proof beyond a reasonable doubt or the preponderance of the evidence are the standards to be applied in determining whether the probation should be revoked. The trial judge must only be reasonably satisfied from the evidence that the probationer has violated conditions of his probation. Fiorella v. State,
40 Ala. App. 587 ,121 So.2d 875 (1960)."
In the case of Free, supra, it is pointed out that while a "mere arrest" or the filing of charges themselves would be insufficient grounds for revocation of probation, it is equally clear that neither our statute nor the constitution requires a final conviction of probationer of the offense charged before his probation may be revoked. The court further stated: "But while the standard of proof is not reasonable doubt or the preponderance of the evidence, Armstrong v. State, supra, `the State must submit substantive evidence to reasonably satisfy the trier of the facts that a condition of probation has been breached.' Hill v. State, supra [
Considering the entire record, including the evidence that marijuana cigarettes were found in the ash tray of the automobile owned and driven by the appellant, we are clear to the conclusion that there was adequate evidence from which the trial court could have reasonably held that the appellant had breached the terms of his probation. The judgment of the trial court revoking probation is affirmed.
The foregoing opinion was prepared by the Honorable THOMAS E. HUEY, Jr., Retired Circuit Judge, temporarily on duty on the court pursuant to §
AFFIRMED.
All the Judges concur. *Page 1208
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Willie E. Nicholson v. State.
- Cited By
- 7 cases
- Status
- Published