Nelson v. Dunaway
Nelson v. Dunaway
Opinion of the Court
This appeal arises from the granting of a directed verdict.
As a result of an automobile accident between plaintiff and Dunaway, plaintiff sued B.J.'s Lounge (defendant-lounge), contending that the defendant-lounge dispensed alcoholic beverages to Dunaway contrary to the following regulatory provision: "No on premise licensee may serve a person any alcoholic beverage if such person is acting in such a manner as to appear to be intoxicated," Ala. Adm. Code, Vol. 1, ABC Bd., Reg.
At the close of all of the evidence, the trial court granted the defendant-lounge's motion for a directed verdict. The plaintiff appeals, and we affirm.
The plaintiff contends that the trial court erred by not submitting the case to the jury, arguing that there was a scintilla of evidence to support the dram shop claim against the defendant-lounge. We disagree.
One of the elements of a cause of action under the Dram Shop Act is that the defendant provide alcoholic beverages to the intoxicated person who caused the accident. Martin v. Watts,
This case is due to be affirmed.
AFFIRMED.
BRADLEY, P.J., and INGRAM, J., concur.
Addendum
On rehearing plaintiff, for some unknown reason, contends that this court lacked jurisdiction to entertain this appeal. Needless to say, we disagree.
Plaintiff contends that this court is "confused" as to its jurisdiction. We would point out, however, that this case wastransferred to this court by the supreme court, and we know of no power this court has to refuse the supreme court's order of transfer. In other words, we now exercise jurisdiction because the supreme court transferred it to us. Branch v. Greene CountyBoard of Education,
We note that any quarrel the plaintiff may have concerning jurisdiction of this case would be with the supreme court and not with this court. We do note, as a matter of interest only, however, that we agree with the supreme court that this case should have properly been before this court.
OPINION EXTENDED; APPLICATION FOR REHEARING OVERRULED.
BRADLEY, P.J., and INGRAM, J., concur. *Page 957
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Carl John Nelson and St. Paul Fire Marine Insurance Company v. Walter Lee Dunaway
- Cited By
- 5 cases
- Status
- Published