Day v. State
Day v. State
Opinion
This is an appeal by Robert Day of his conviction for the attempted murder of one Ronnie Johnson. Appellant was found guilty by a Lee County jury, was sentenced to 20 years' imprisonment, and was ordered to pay restitution in the amount of $425 to Johnson and $2,958 to Isabelle Patterson.
The record reveals that, on November 27, 1987, Johnson went to visit Henry Key at his apartment, but Key was not home. Johnson sat down to talk with Isabelle Patterson, Key's neighbor, while he waited for Key to return. Appellant and Reginald Henderson arrived at Key's home and came in through the back door. As appellant entered, Johnson and Patterson heard him say in a low tone, "I feel like killing somebody tonight." Appellant came into the room where Johnson and Patterson were seated and demanded that Patterson, a former girlfriend, come outside with him. When she refused, he slapped her and said, "Do you want me to do it here?" She asked, "Do what?" and shoved him. At that, appellant drew a gun from under his shirt and pointed it at Johnson's head. Afraid to turn his head, Johnson put his hand up to turn the muzzle. Appellant said, "Don't grab it or I'll shoot you." Johnson then heard a shot, and Patterson said, "He shot me in the leg." Appellant chased Johnson outside, firing at him four or five more times and striking him in the leg and shoulder. Appellant fled the premises before the police arrived, but turned himself in on January 10, 1988. The gun was never found.
Appellant was indicted for the attempted murder of Ronnie Johnson and, at trial, the state's case was largely uncontradicted. At the conclusion of the trial, the court ordered a restitution hearing, at which it accepted evidence concerning the medical expenses of both Johnson and Patterson. Thereafter, he ordered restitution to be paid to both, and appellant objected, arguing that restitution to Patterson was improper because there was a case pending regarding appellant's criminal liability for Patterson's injuries and that restitution would not be appropriate unless he was found guilty on those charges. On appeal Day contends that the trial court erred in ordering restitution to Patterson. We agree.
Section
"[I]t is essential to be fair and impartial in the administration of justice, that all perpetrators of criminal activity or conduct be required to fully compensate all victims of such conduct or activity for *Page 1319 any percuniary loss, damage or injury as a direct or indirect result thereof."
"Criminal activities" is defined at §
It is clear that this statute authorizes the trial court to order a defendant to pay restitution to any person who falls within the definition of "victim" and who suffered either direct or indirect pecuniary losses as a result of the defendant's activity for which he has been convicted or to which he has admitted. We have construed the term "victim" to encompass persons who were not necessarily the primary object of defendant's criminal conduct. See Kyser v. State,
If it could be said that Patterson's injury arose from appellant's attempted murder of Johnson, for which he was convicted, then she could properly be characterized as a victim, and restitution to her would be proper. However, when one suffers a loss which resulted from conduct that was not the subject of the defendant's prosecution and for which a subsequent prosecution would be necessary to determine the defendant's criminal liability, if any, we hold that an order of restitution to that person is no more appropriate than would be the sentencing of the defendant to a term of imprisonment without first affording him the basic constitutional guarantees of a trial and verdict on those charges. Appellant should not have been ordered to pay restitution to Patterson.
For the reasons stated above, that portion of the judgment of the trial court ordering restitution in the amount of $2,958 to Isabelle Patterson is reversed, and the trial court is instructed to amend its judgment accordingly. However, the judgment of conviction and sentence of 20 years' imprisonment and the order of restitution in the amount of $425 to Ronnie Johnson for the attempted murder of Ronnie Johnson stands, and it is hereby affirmed.
AFFIRMED IN PART; REVERSED IN PART.
All Judges concur. *Page 1320
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Robert Day, Alias v. State.
- Cited By
- 15 cases
- Status
- Published