Prather v. City of Hoover
Prather v. City of Hoover
Opinion
The appellant, Gregory Dale Prather, was convicted, after a jury trial, of driving under the influence of alcohol, in violation of a municipal ordinance of the City of Hoover. He raises three issues on appeal; however, we need only address the City of Hoover's failure to introduce the ordinance by which it adopted §
At trial, the City of Hoover attempted to offer Ordinance No. 83-386, which adopted §
"MS. ARNOLD [the prosecutor]: The ordinance that we presented at the very first is the adopting ordinance that incorporates the State law.
"THE COURT: None of that is evidence. Okay? Those are just procedural matters that concern us. . . ." (Emphasis added.)
It appears from the record that the City of Hoover's Exhibit number 1, Ordinance No. 83-386, was marked for identification. Examining the record as a whole, however, we simply cannot ascertain that the adopting ordinance was ever introduced into evidence and, thus, considered by the jury.
The appellant relies on Ex parte Maxwell,
Maxwell has recently been reaffirmed by the Alabama Supreme Court in Ex parte Woodson,"[I]t is well established that in a criminal prosecution for violation of a city ordinance the city must plead and prove the ordinance. Cooper v. Town of Valley Head,
212 Ala. 125 ,101 So. 874 (1924); Jacobs v. City of Prichard,46 Ala. App. 497 ,243 So.2d 769 (1971); Thompson v. City of Sylacauga,30 Ala. App. 72 ,200 So. 795 (1941). And it has been held when the city does not introduce the ordinance into evidence, it has failed to make out its case against the defendant and the trial court has erred in pronouncing the judgment of conviction. Jacobs v. City of Prichard, supra; Felder v. City *Page 259 of Huntsville,42 Ala. App. 488 ,168 So.2d 490 (1964); Thompson v. City of Sylacauga, supra."
Thus, we hold that, because the City of Hoover failed to introduce the ordinance, which adopted §
REVERSED AND RENDERED.
All Judges concur.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Gregory Dale Prather v. City of Hoover.
- Cited By
- 15 cases
- Status
- Published