McGee v. State
McGee v. State
Opinion of the Court
The appellant, Donnell McGee, was convicted of the unlawful distribution of a controlled substance, a violation of §
The trial court complied with our directions and resentenced the appellant to seven years' imprisonment, plus five years under §
The state has asked that we remand this cause to the trial court so that that court can modify its sentence to reflect the original sentence of 12 years and to add the 5-year penalty under §
" 'On remand, the issues decided by the appellate court become law of the case and the trial court's duty is to comply with the appellate mandate "according to its true intent and meaning, as determined by the directions given by the reviewing court." ' Walker v. Carolina Mills Lumber Co.,
441 So.2d 980 (Ala.Civ.App. 1983), citing Ex parte Alabama Power Co.,431 So.2d 151 (Ala. 1983)."
We agree. "The trial judge lost all jurisdiction to modify the original sentence 30 days after its imposition," when no motion for a new trial was made within that 30-day time period.Massey v. State,
Dissenting Opinion
I dissent from the majority's holding that the trial court had no authority to resentence the appellant to a reduced term of two years before that term was further enhanced by two additional five-year penalties under §§
The trial court's resentencing did not violate the holding ofLynch v. State,
A trial court has the authority to reconsider and toreduce a defendant's sentence upon motion timely made. "For the most part, the applicable statutes and rules of court explicitly state or have been construed to mean that the trial judge may reduce the sentence but may not increase the sentence he previously imposed." 3 W. LaFave J. Israel, CriminalProcedure § 25.2(e) at 132-33 (1984). On the other hand, "[o]nce a valid sentence has been entered, it cannot, in the absence of fraud or another compelling reason, be altered anytime thereafter so as to increase the severity of the sentence." Ex parte Tice,
(M.D.Ala. 1967), affirmed,
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Donnell McGee v. State.
- Cited By
- 12 cases
- Status
- Published