Scott v. The J. C. Rich
Scott v. The J. C. Rich
Opinion of the Court
This suit is brought by libelant to recover a sum of money claimed to be due him for work and labor done as ship carpenter under a contract with the owner of said tug. The proof shows that the work was done on the vessel in completing her construction, and rendering her fit for the uses for which she was designed. It shows that the tug, when partly constructed, was launched and sunk for preservation; that she was then without shoe, rudder, engine, stern-plate, house, steering-gear, bunks, or boilers; that she remained in this condition some considerable time, was subsequently raised, and libelant contracted to do certain necessary carpenter’s work to complete her. She was not enrolled and licensed and finished as a complete vessel, as originally designed, until after libelant’s work on her. The proof further shows that from the laying of her keel she was destined to become a steam-tug, was suitable for nothing else, was never completed for any other use, and had not been used for the purposes of commerce and navigation until after the work done on her by the libelant. What the libelant did, therefore, must be held to have been done in the original construction of the vessel. In order to the existence of the admiralty jurisdiction in this court, the
The libel in this case must be dismissed, and it is so ordered.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- The J. C. Rich. Scott v. The J. C. Rich
- Status
- Published