Innerarity v. Hitchcock
Innerarity v. Hitchcock
Opinion of the Court
This is an action of trespass, to • try titles, brought in the Circuit court of Mobile.
After the trial term had passed, and the cause continued, at the next succeeding- term, the defendant moved for, and obtained, a change of venue, to Clarke county.
The plaintiff has applied to this court, to interpose, and supersede, and vacate, the order of the Circuit court of Mobile county; and for an injunction to the Circuit court of Clarke county, enjoining that court from receiving, or trying, the cause, &c.
The only question presented for our consideration is, whether it was competent for the Circuit court of Mobile county, to award a change of venue, in this action, after the first trial term had passed.
-Before the passage of the first act, the practice of the courts had been to grant changes of venue, by the rule of the .common law, in actions purely personal, on a sufficient showing, made "by the party asking such change. But the exercise of this power was not confined to the trial term. In actions local, such as real or mixed, it was not the practice to grant a change ox venue, under any circumstances; nor was it believed to be within the competent common law powers of the court to do so. But as cases of the latter description often occurred, where the ends of justice could not be obtained without such change of venue, the act of 1818, was passed to remedy the evil.
The act of 1819, was intended, from its terms, to embrace the whole subject of a change of venue, for the purpose of obtaining a fair and impartial trial.— The terms employed are too comprehensive to admit of a doubt, but, that the Legislature had it in view, to extend its provisions to every kind of action, that could be instituted in a court of law. And having the whole subject under consideration, it was thought expedient to limit the time when such change of venue should be made.
The last act, although it is restrictive as to the time when a change of venue shall be ordered, contains another feature, that seems to me to be essen-
Reference
- Full Case Name
- INNERARITY versus HITCHCOCK
- Status
- Published