Granberry v. Wellborn
Granberry v. Wellborn
Opinion of the Court
It has been repeatedly holden,that where the common counts in assumpsit ar'e added to a count on a note, that the plaintiff may take a final judgment by default, although no particular disposition is made -of the common counts. The amount of the recovery, however, should not exceed the sum expressed in the note with interest. [Graves v. Lake, at this term, and cases there cited.] It is objected that in the present case, the judgment falls short of the note, five hundred dollars, and it cannot be intended that it is for the money thereby promised to be paid. This argument is not defensible. The reasonable inference is, that the note had been reduced by payments; and this- is authorized by the principle which requires that all fair presumptions shall be made on error, in favor of the judgments of inferior Courts.
2. The second section of the act of 1818, enacts, “Whenever a writ shall issue against any two or more joint, or joint and several obligors, covenanters or drawers, of any such bond, covenant,'bill or promissory note, or against two or more of the defendants to any such joint judgment, it shall be lawful for the plaintiff or his attorney, -at any time after the return of said writ, or an alias writ, to discontinue such action against any one or more of the defendants, on whom such writ, or alias writ, shall not have been executed, and proceed to judgment against any one or more of said defendants on whom said writ shall have been executed, or proceed to issue an alias or plu-ries writ, at his election. This statute does not make the return of non est inventus the only evidence of the non-execution of the process; and where the return affirms its execution on one of two defendants, but is silent as to the other, the legal conclusion is, that there was no service' on the latter. Under such circumstances a discontinuance is authorized by the act cited. [Aik Dig. 267.]
Reference
- Full Case Name
- GRANBERRY v. WELLBORN, use, &c.
- Status
- Published