Pool v. Harrison
Cases that cite this one
10 later published cases cite this decision.
- Hatton v. Howard Braiding Co. (R.I. 1925)
- City of Prichard v. Hawkins (Ala. 1951)
- Paulausky v. Polish Roman Catholic Union (Ind. 1942)
- Julian v. Nicholson (8th Cir. 1934)
- Russell v. Bush (Ala. 1916)
- In re Federal Biscuit Co. (2d Cir. 1914)
- City Deposit Bank v. Green (Iowa 1908)
- Marsh's Administrator v. Richardson's Administrator (Ala. 1873)
- Mahone v. Williams (Ala. 1863)
- Evans v. Kittrell (Ala. 1859)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
This case was before this court at a previous term. — 16 Ala. 167. We have carefully examined the opinion in that case, and find that it covers the material points raised upon the record before us. We think it very clear that the unqualified surrender by Pool to Kirkland Harrison, the administrator, of the slaves in dispute, as assets of the estate of Richard Harrison, deceased, and the subsequent distribution of them among the next of kin, without any objection from him, all which was done by order of the Orphans’ Court and with Pool’s concurrence or rather without objection from him, completely estops him from afterwards claiming the slaves, as against the administrator. The pleas which set up this estoppel were good, and are fully sustained by the previous decision made in this cause. — 16 Ala. 175, et seq. Nor does it make any difference whether said slaves were surrendered upon the demand of the administrator or were voluntarily brought forward and delivered by Pool without such demand; nor whether the administrator regarded them as property of said estate, and so returned them in his inventory, before such delivery was made. The gist of the estoppel is that Pool delivered thenr to the administrator as assets for distribution, and they were accordingly distributed. He should not then be heard to complain against the administrator, and hold him liable for the consequences resulting from his own act. But it is unnecessary to elaborate this point or to cite authorities in support of it. It is very clear the pleas of estoppel, pleaded as they were in short by the consent of counsel, were substantially correct, and the several replications to them were bad.
As to the joint replication to both these pleas, it did not deny the estoppel, but avered that the plaintiff was entitled to the slaves by the will of Richard B. Harrison, thus going behind the estoppel, and attempting to set up the claim upon which the estoppel operated as valid notwithstanding. — 1 Chitty’s Pl. 604.
The only remaining point is the action taken by the court upon the interrogatories, filed by the plaintiff for discovery, under the statute. — Clay’s Dig. 341, § 160. We think the court had the discretionary power to allow the defendant to answer after the expiration of the sixty days named in the statute, and to allow him to amend the answer filed by him, there appearing a sufficient excuse, in the estimation of the primary court, for granting such indulgence. This being the exercise of a discretion on the part of the court below, this court will not reverse it. This view harmonizes with the decision made by our predecessors in the case of Goodwin, use, &c. v. Harrison, 6 Ala. 438.
We are unable to perceive any error in the record, and the judgment is consequently affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.