Watkins v. Tuskaloosa & Northport Manufacturing Co.
Watkins v. Tuskaloosa & Northport Manufacturing Co.
Opinion of the Court
The bill is filed by Watkins, to obtain a decree for the value of his interest as a stockholder in the Tuskaloosa and Northport Manufacturing Company. lie founds his right to a decree upon the agreement set forth in “Exhibit A” to Ipis bill.
But he is not entitled to the. decree which he seeks, unless he has done, or offered to do, all that the agreement required him to do, or shows a valid legal excuse for not having done or offered to do all that the agreement required him to do.
The agreement clearly required him to refer, or to offer to refer, the ascertainment of the value of his interest as
This allegation shows, that Watkins was not even willing that the value of his interest as a stockholder should be ascertained in the mode provided for in the agreement, unless the company, in selecting the referee whom it had the right by the agreement to select, would choose one that Watkins thought was suitable. It is very certain that, if the company was willing to select a referee who was in fact suitable, Watkins’ opinion that he was unsuitable could not excuse Watkins for preventing the ascertainment of the value in the mode provided for in the agreement. The bill does not even allege the unsuitableness of the referee who was selected or about to be selected by the company; but alleges only the opinion of Watkins that he was unsuitable.
Whether, alter Watkins has in vain done, or offered to do, all that the agreement requires him to do, in order to get the value of his interest ascertained in the mode therein specified, he may not be entitled to invoke the aid of the chancery court, we shall not now consider. But it is clear that, without doing, or offering to do, more than his bill shows he has done or offered to do, to have the value of his interest as a stockholder ascertained in
The decree of the chancellor is affirmed, at the costs of appellant.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- WATKINS v. TUSKALOOSA AND NORTHPORT MANUFACTURING COMPANY
- Status
- Published