Beene's Adm'r v. Collenberger & Co.
Cases that cite this one
8 later published cases cite this decision.
- Union Stave Co. v. Smith (Ala. 1896)
- Roberts v. Grayson (Ala. 1937)
- Estate of Le Clerc (California Superior Court, San Francisco County 1887)
- Hayes v. Woods (Ala. 1882)
- Lesslie v. Richardson (Ala. 1877)
- Riddle v. Hill's Administrator (Ala. 1874)
- Halfman's v. Ellison & Sons (Ala. 1874)
- Wilson v. Armstrong (Ala. 1868)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
The decree in this case must be reversed, for a defect in the amended affidavit of verification. The amended affidavit is sufficient, if it had established the claim against the proper estate. It proves the claim against the estate of Jesse Beene, deceased, instead of Benjamin Y. Beene. This may be a clerical error, but we find it carried into both the original and amended records.
Here this opinion might close; but we feel it our duty to pass on the merits of the controversy.
We deeply lament the result we are compelled to arrive at in this case. It works a most palpable. injustice, from which we would gladly relieve the purchasers at the void sale. We have struggled to find some argument, by which we could arrive at a different result, but have found none. The decisions of this court have left the law arising on questions growing out of void sales by administrators, in a deplorable state of confusion and hardship. This we could not relieve, without boldly disregarding and overruling principles which have long been considered as settled. The evils consequent upon a change of decision, might, and probably would, be greater than will result from an adherence to former adjudications. Another coordinate branch of the government can apply the corrective, without disturbing titles and possessions which now rest in confident security.
This opinion has been prepared near two years. We have held it up, in the hope that we might find some solution of the question more accordant with our wishes. Our
Reversed and remanded.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.