Supreme Court of Alabama, 1882

McKenzie v. Gibson

McKenzie v. Gibson
Supreme Court of Alabama · Decided December 15, 1882 · Stone
73 Ala. 204

McKenzie v. Gibson

Opinion of the Court

STONE, J.

— We find no error in the récord. The complaint filed before the justice claims a penalty under section 1587 of tbe Code of 18'76. The statute provides no special remedy for the penalty therein denounced. The penal part of the demand can not be recovered in an action of trespass. Tbe suit must be on the statute, and is in its nature an action of debt. A count in trespass vi et armis can not be joined with such complaint, nor can it, on appeal, be substituted for it. It changes tbe form of the action, which is not allowable. Jean v. Sandiford, 39 Ala. 317; Crimm v. Crawford, 29 Ala. 623; Beavers v. Hardie, 59 Ala. 570; 1 Brick. Dig. 526, §§ 19, 20.

Affirmed.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.