Ex parte Barker
Cases that cite this one
2 later published cases cite this decision.
- Johns v. Cannon (Ala. 1917)
- Ex parte Hurt (Ala. 1908)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
The facts shown by the petition and answer may be stated to be these: One Barker died seized and possessed of a certain tract of land comprising 378 acres, and personal property, leaving a widow and these petitioners as his heirs at law. At the time of his death, he resided upon the land with his wife, and she is now residing upon it. Situate near their dwelling was another dwelling, vdiich Avas occupied by R. C. Barker,
■ She further alleges that it is necessary, that the pos-, session of said land be taken from -said Barker, and that Carroll, to whom she had rented the land, be placed in possession of the same. And that the rents -when collected from him -should'he held by the administratrix of -said estate to await the action and decision of the court upon her-rights to dower and homestead and that when the same is so -ascertained, that said rents be applied by the -court and paid to those who are entitled to the same.
The complainants in the bill, petitioners here, answered this, petition and unon a hearing the chancellor made an order directing Barker to deliver the possession of the land to Carroll within ten days. It was further ordered that if the possession was not delivered as
From the foregoing statement of facts and allegations of the pleadings in the cause and decretal orders, it is manifest that the chancellor did nothing more than he should have done. The court had jurisdiction of the parties and the subject matter over which the controversy arose. It became the duty of the court in administering the estate not only to protect the rights of the respective contestants to the extent of their claim or interest in the property belonging to the estate, but also the rights of creditors. The petition .for the renting of the lands not only discloses the claims of the widow, but also the fact that the time for the presentation of claims by creditors had not expired and that the- administratrix was not informed, and for that matter could not be, as to the extent of the indebtedness of her intestate.
Having held the plea of the widow sufficient, it becomes a question of proof of the facts' alleged in it. Pending the trial of that issue, should the court decline to direct the renting out of the lands, leaving them in the possession of B. C. Barker, whose right to their possession is subordinate to the widow’s right of quarantine, it is apparent that she would lose the rent of them if she is successful. If unsuccessful, • petitioners have lost nothing, as the rents collected by the administratrix will be distributed to them upon a settlement unless they are required to pay the debts of the estate. If they are needed for this purpose, so much greater the reason for upholding the action of the chancellor.
We do not deem it necessary to discuss the question as to the right of an administrator to the possession of lands belonging to his intestate’s estate as against the heir for the purpose of renting them out during the period within which creditors of the decedent have the right to present claims. It would seem from the cases of Golding v. Golding, 24 Ala. 124; Tarver v. Smith, 38 Ala. 137; Calhoun v. Fletcher, 63 Ala. 580, and Langford v. Dunklin & Reese, 71 Ala. 605, and authorities cited in these cases, that he has such right.
The writ of mandamus must be denied.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.