Tolbert v. Falkenberry
Tolbert v. Falkenberry
Opinion of the Court
The complainant below J. H, Falkenberry, appellee, here, bases his right to relief upon the grounds, as alleged, that he furnished to the defendant .Stewart, contain materials for the erection of a house upon the. land, for which he claims a material-man’s lien, which, by proceedings set out in the hill, he attemptetd to perfect. He alleges, he brought suit in the court of a justice of the peace, upon the account for the payment of which he sought to have declared a lien on the land on which.tlie house was built and to have the same enforced; that he recovered a judgment in said court of the justice of the peace for the sum of'$68.54 and the costs of suit, and a lien was declared on the property described, and
The defendants demurred to the bill as amended on many grounds, among them being the one, that set up in substance that J. M. Snead, a justice of the peace who rendered the judgment and declared a material-man’s lien for its enforcement, had no jurisdiction to render said judgment, and establish such lien.
The’jurisdiction of a justice of the peace-to render a judgment and declare a lien of this character is wholly a creation of statute. Until the passage of the statute embodied in Section 2733 of the Code of 1896, a justice was without any jurisdiction in such matters. That section provides that “where the amount involved exceeds fifty dollars, actions for the enforcement of liens under this article may be brought in the circuit court, or court hav ing like jurisdiction, or in the chancery court of the county in which the property is situated, and when resort is had to the chancery court, no special ground of equitable jurisdiction need be alleged or proved. In all other cases actions to enforce such liens shall be brought before justices of the peace.” We are of the opinion, that when the amount of the claim exceeds fifty dollars, as in this case, a justice of the peace is without any jurisdiction to entertain an action for the enforcement of a mechanic’s or material man’s lien, and to render a judgment looking to the enforcement of said lien.
Reversed and rendered.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.