City of Montgomery v. Greene
Cases that cite this one
8 later published cases cite this decision.
- WATER WORKS BD. OF CITY OF BIRMINGHAM v. Barnes (Ala. 1983)
- City of Roanoke v. Fisher (Va. 1952)
- City of Texarkana v. Wiggins (Tex. 1952)
- Town of Cordova v. Alaska Public Utilities (United States District Court for the District of Alaska 1937)
- City of Montgomery v. McDade (Ala. 1914)
- Town & Country Apartments & Townhouses v. City of Richmond (Richmond City Circuit Court 1972)
- State Ex Rel. Lammons v. Commander (Ala. 1924)
- City of Montgomery v. Smith (Ala. 1921)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
It may be conceded that the city is under no obligation to supply an ordinary out-lander with water, or to do so at the same rate as those
That the bill avers and the proof shows that the city has entended its system to the locality embracing these complainants, and which was within the police jurisdiction at the time, though now designated as the town of Cloverdale, there is no doubt. Indeed this was practically admitted by one of the appellant’s counsel and which said admission is, we think, fully justified by the record. Therefore, with this question settled, this case must be affirmed, unless we recede from our former opinion as reported in 180 Ala. 322,.60 South, p. 900, to the effect that, in the absence of some physical difference so as to justify a separate classification, these complainants must be supplied with water at the same rate as those of the same class whether in the town of Cloverdale or the city of Montgomery, and that the mere fact that one was within and the other beyond the corporate limits of the city did not afford a basis for a separate and distinct classification. It is conceded that the former holding is sound if we were dealing with an ordinary water company undertaking to supply water for a profit, instead of with a municipality which had undertaken
The decree of the chancery court is affirmed.
Affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.