Sanitary Plumbing Co. v. Simpson
Sanitary Plumbing Co. v. Simpson
Opinion of the Court
Plaintiff (appellant here) brought suit against the appellees for the purpose of establishing and enforcing a mechanic’s and materialman’s lien upon a two-story brick residence in Decatur, Ala., as provided by article 1, c. 107, Code 1907. The contract, as disclosed by the complaint, for the erection of this dwelling, was entered into by W. II. Simpson, now deceased, with one Ross as the original contractor, and the plaintiffs then entered into a contract with said Ross for the installation of the plumbing in this building. The suit was originally brought against said (Ross, the contractor, and Mary D. Simpson as executrix of the estate of W. II. Simpson, deceased, and also against her individually; but when the cause was called for trial the complaint was amended by striking out said Ross as a party defendant. The trial resulted in a judgment for defendant, and the only assignments of error here insisted upon are those relating to the action of the couft in sustaining demurrer to some of the counts of the complaint as originally framed.
In Cook v. Rome Brick Co., 98 Ala. 409, 12 South. 918, it was held that, in actions of this character, the facts necessary to the creation of a lien must be alleged and proven, and indeed such is the language of section 4765 of the Code .of 1907. We think it clear that the .complaint should allége who was the owner or proprietor of the property upon which the lien is sought to be establised. Section 4754 et seq., Code 1907; Wadsworth v. Hodge, 88 Ala. 500, 7 South. 194; Hawkins Lumber Co. v. Brown, 100 Ala. 217, 14 South. 110; First Ave. C. & L. Co. v. McWilson, 182 Ala. 276, 62 South. 531; .27 Cyc. 374; 13 Enc. P. & P. 969, 970. There was no error, therefore, in this ruling of the court. For like reason, the action of the court in sustaining demurrer to some of the other counts of the complaint was justified.
We have here discussed the only questions argued by counsel for appellant, and, finding no error, the judgment of the court below will be affirmed.
Affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- SANITARY PLUMBING CO. v. SIMPSON Et Al.
- Cited By
- 6 cases
- Status
- Published