Newman v. Martin
Newman v. Martin
Opinion of the Court
The present bill was filed by the appellants against the appellee, seeking the annulment of the probate of the will of Sara A. Newman, deceased. In one aspect the bill discloses that it is filed by the complainants as heirs of said Sara A. Newman, and no contest was entered in the probate court when the will was offered for probate. Grounds for contest are alleged to ■he unsoundness of mind of the testatrix and undue influence exercised upon her in the execution of the will. The bill was filed within the period fixed by section 6207 of the Code of 1907, and the demurrer interposed to this phase of the bill was overruled.
The matter alleged, therefore, not being grounds for contest in the probate court, could not be made so by a bill in equity filed under the statute. Nor could the question of the alleged estoppel be presented in such a statutory proceeding. In Ex parte Walter, 202 Ala. 281, 80 South. 119, this court held, following in the wake of McCann v. Ellis, 172 Ala. 60, 55 South. 303, and authorities therein cited, that a proceeding of this character was a proceeding in rem, and exclusively for the determination of the status of the res, and not the rights of the parties. Under this authority, therefore, it is very clear that this matter of quasi estoppel could not he, here set up in a statutory bill of this character, and the court below correctly ruled in sustaining the demurrer to this feature of the hill.
Let the decree be here affirmed.
Affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- NEWMAN Et Al v. MARTIN
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published