Supreme Court of Alabama, 1941

Emerson v. State

Emerson v. State
Supreme Court of Alabama · Decided April 10, 1941 · Bouldin, Gardner, Foster, Livingston
1 So. 2d 605; 241 Ala. 141; 1941 Ala. LEXIS 341 (Southern Reporter, Second Series)

Emerson v. State

Opinion of the Court

*142 BOULDIN, Justice.

The holding of the Court of Appeals that the additional instruction given the jury was free from reversible error upon a consideration of the entire charge is sustained on examination of the record.

The excerpt' quoted in the opinion was only a part of the supplemental instruction. The court proceeded at the time to reassert there should be no conviction unless satisfied of guilt from the evidence beyond a reasonable doubt; and further instructed, that if they so found, they need not impose a fine, but in their discretion, could leave the punishment to be fixed by the court. Code of 1923, § 5268.

That the jury was not misled is indicated by the fact that they did not assess a fine, but expressly by their verdict, left the fixing of punishment to the court.

The court having imposed hard labor for the county as a punishment for the offense, there was no error in imposing a further period of hard labor for costs. Code of 1923, § 5291.

Writ denied.

GARDNER, C. J., and FOSTER, and LIVINGSTON, JJ., concur.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.