Supreme Court of Arkansas, 2008

Tuck v. Arkansas Department of Human Services

Tuck v. Arkansas Department of Human Services
Supreme Court of Arkansas · Decided December 4, 2008 · Per Curiam
289 S.W.3d 420; 375 Ark. 177; 2008 Ark. LEXIS 716 (South Western Reporter, Third Series)

Tuck v. Arkansas Department of Human Services

Opinion

Per Curiam.

Rule 2-4 of the Rules of the Arkansas Supreme Court require petitions for review to “briefly and distinctly state the basis upon which the case should be reviewed” and “may include citations to authority or references to statutes or constitutional provisions.” Although subsection (b) of that rule prohibits briefs in support of review petitions, it allows petitioners to attach a copy of their petition for rehearing before the Court of Appeals. Rule 2-3 dictates the procedure and requirements of petitions for rehearing and allows a brief in support to be filed with a petition for rehearing.

Appellee, the Arkansas Department of Human Services, claimed in its petition for review that the Court of Appeals “made errors of fact and law and should be reversed.” The petition fails to note with particularity what it believes those errors to be and upon what grounds this court should grant review. Although Appel-lee attached its petition for rehearing, it is a nearly identical copy of the review petition and gives no additional argument or citation to authority. Appellee also attached its Brief in Support of Petition for Rehearing to its review petition, and it is in that document that Appellee makes its substantive argument regarding the errors it believes the appellate court made. Because Rule 2-4 prohibits this court from accepting briefs in support of petitions for review, we cannot consider the arguments made in the Brief in Support of the Petition for Rehearing.

For purposes of clarification to the Bar, this court will only consider the Petition for Review filed with this court pursuant to Rule 2-4 and, if attached to the review petition, the Petition for Rehearing to the Court of Appeals. It will not accept a brief in support of the review petition and will not consider a brief in support of the rehearing petition.

Appellee’s petition for review is denied.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.