U. S. Maluia v. Tago
U. S. Maluia v. Tago
Opinion of the Court
OPINION OF THE COURT
Tago filed his application with the Registrar of Titles to have certain land designated as Asofitu in the Village of Nu’uuli registered as the communal family land of the Tago Family. A survey of the land proposed to be registered accompanied the application. The land is. on the mountain side of the main highway going from Fagatogo to Leone. The land offered for registration is in fact only a part of the larger tract of land generally known as Asofitu.
Maluia of Nu’uuli filed an objection to the proposed registration claiming that the land involved was the communal property of the Maluia Family. Prior to the hearing, the Court viewed the property in the presence of both parties.
Maluia, who is 62 years old, testified that the Maluia people cleared the land from the bush and put in plantations on it, and that about 1906 or 1907 Maluia Akeimo gave the land to Tago Sifaga to serve the Tago title. Maluia further testified that he saw it cleared when he was a small boy. If he is correct as to seeing it cleared, it was necessarily cleared after the Government was established in 1900, since Maluia is only 62 years old. Maluia testified that he was six or seven years old when the gift was made. Maluia also claimed that the land was given to Tago Sifaga for his personal use. Tago Sifaga died in 1951 and was succeeded in that year by Tago Leti, the present Tago.
We think that the testimony of Maluia that the land was given to Tago Sifaga to serve the Tago title is somewhat inconsistent with his testimony that it was given to Tago Sifaga for his personal use. We furthermore think that Maluia was so young in 1906 or 1907 (he was only six or seven years old then) when the gift was made that he would have no knowledge about the nature of the gift, and that his testimony is based purely on hearsay 55 or 56 years after the gift was made, and is, therefore, not very reliable.
It is our conclusion from the evidence that this land is Tago communal family land.
DECREE
Accordingly, it is ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED that the land Asofitu as shown on the survey accompanying the application to register the same as the communal family land of the Tago Family of Nu’uuli shall be registered as the communal family land of the Tago Family of Nu’uuli.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.