Clark v. Pacific Gas & Electric Co.
Cases that cite this one
10 later published cases cite this decision.
- Garcia v. Soogian (Cal. 1959)
- Hopper v. Bulaich (Cal. 1945)
- Salt River Valley Water Users' Ass'n v. Compton Ex Rel. Compton (Ariz. 1932)
- SPUR FEEDING COMPANY v. Fernandez (Ariz. Ct. App. 1970)
- Lopez v. Capitol Co. (Cal. Ct. App. 1956)
- Adams v. Southern Pacific Co. (Cal. Ct. App. 1947)
- Kataoka v. May Department Stores Co. (United States District Court for the Southern District of California 1939)
- Lambert v. Western Pacific Railroad (Cal. Ct. App. 1933)
- Salt River Valley Water Users' Ass'n v. Compton (Ariz. 1932)
- Brown v. Southern California Edison Co. (Cal. Ct. App. 1932)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
The plaintiff had judgment in the sum of $4,250 for and on account of damages alleged to have been suffered by reason of coming in contact with a high-powered electric transmission line, negligently maintained by the defendant. From this judgment the defendant appeals, and also from an order denying defendant's motion for judgment in its favor, notwithstanding the verdict.
The complaint alleges that on the third day of May, 1929, the defendant was maintaining a power transmission line suspended on poles, in and over the Cutten-McDonald tract, near or adjacent to the city of Eureka; that the volume of electricity carried in said line amounted to about 2,300 volts; that upon the poles the defendant caused steps to be maintained from the top thereof to within a few feet of the ground (the testimony showing about 18 inches); that said steps were maintained contrary to an order of the railroad commission known as and called "General Order 64-A"; that the order referred to became effective March 1, 1929, and specifies that the lowest step on any pole supporting an electric power line shall not be less than 7 feet 6 inches from the ground. It is further alleged in the complaint that the defendant so negligently maintained the pole involved in this action, and carelessly and recklessly maintained the steps thereon so as to become attractive to children, and in such a manner as to constitute an invitation to children to climb thereon, to the danger of said children's lives. It is further alleged that no provisions were made to safeguard and prevent children from climbing the pole involved in this action, or to advise them of the danger thereof, and that the pole was maintained as an attractive nuisance. It is further alleged that on the third day of May, *Page 346 1929, the plaintiff, a minor of the age of twelve years, at that time, while playing with other children, was attracted by the steps on said pole line and climbed from the ground to the top thereof, seizing one of the wires on said pole conducting electricity as aforesaid; that the plaintiff was severely injured, to his damage in the sum of $15,000.
In the second count contained in plaintiff's complaint, after alleging the negligent maintenance of the poles and of the steps, as herein referred to, that the plaintiff, a minor of the age of twelve years, on the third day of May, 1929, was playing on the streets of said Cutten-McDonald tract, and observing the invitation of the defendant in so equipping said high-powered line, and not knowing the danger thereof, and not knowing that said line was a high-powered line or dangerous, the plaintiff being attracted thereto, climbed said pole on the steps provided for that purpose, and accidentally seized a line on such pole then conducting 2,300 volts, and was greatly shocked and injured, etc.
The answer denies the allegations of the complaint, save and except that it admits the maintenance of the power line and the steps thereon.
The appellant summarizes the facts as follows: "Defendant is shown to have maintained, along and inside of the right of way line of a public street in the city of Eureka, and alongside the block where the plaintiff had lived for 9 years, a pole line consisting of wooden poles carrying electric light and power wires. (Just how long the line had existed does not appear.) On the pole involved there were three lag screws on one side, beginning 12 inches from the ground, and so spaced that they might be used for steps climbing to a regular step 80 inches from the ground. From thence, steps continued to the top of the pole 35 feet from the ground, where there was a single crossarm carrying wires. At the time of the accident plaintiff was 12 years and 9 months of age, 5 feet tall; he had been warned by his father not to climb the poles because of the danger that existed in high-powered electric currents. Plaintiff had been warned by other boys to watch out for the wires. At the time of the accident, the plaintiff and several other boys were playing `cowboy and Indian', and desired to place a can upon the pole and use it as a signal. Joe, a brother of the plaintiff, went up the pole first to attach the signal, and *Page 347 then came down, and afterwards Murray went up. Murray went up the pole to place the can at a higher place. It appears that on the top of the pole there was a spike or nail inserted. According to the testimony of some of the witnesses the plaintiff was elected to climb the pole, as the one `that mostly does all the dangerous work'. The plaintiff climbed the pole, using the lag screws as steps. The plaintiff picked out the pole in question because it was easy to climb. Plaintiff climbed to the top of the pole and sat astride of the crossarm, with one leg on each side of the tip of the pole where it extended above the crossarm."
The record further shows that as the plaintiff was going to tie a string fastening the can to the nail on the top of the pole, he started falling backward and grabbed hold of one of the wires to keep himself from falling, testifying that he was not thinking of the danger. In this manner the plaintiff was injured. The plaintiff further testified that he saw steps on the pole and saw that it was easy to climb.
The cause appears to have been tried on the "attractive nuisance" doctrine that the steps maintained by the defendant constituted an invitation for boys to climb thereon, and that the steps, or spikes answering the purpose of steps, were maintained in violation of General Order No. 64-A of the Railroad Commission. The pole in question was maintained by the defendant on a public street or highway, and therefore all cases dealing with private premises upon which poles are erected are inapplicable to any of the issues involved herein. Both the plaintiff and the defendant had equal rights to be upon the public highways, and the trepass, if any, as claimed by the defendant, could only consist in the climbing of the pole.
[1] Upon this appeal the defendant urges that there is no evidence that the defendant knew or had reason to believe that the pole constituted a dangerous attraction to children; that there is no evidence that the pole was novel or uncommon to the plaintiff, etc.; that the evidence fails to bring the plaintiff within the class designated as of tender and immature years, etc.; that the danger could not have been remedied easily as to boys of plaintiff's age and size; and finally, that the evidence shows that plaintiff was injured as a result of the common and usual risk and hazards, etc. It *Page 348 is further urged that the court erred in its instructions to the jury.
The rule as to the character of instrumentality is thus stated in 19 California Jurisprudence, page 625 et seq.: "An owner of a thing dangerous and attractive to children is not always and universally liable for injury to a child tempted by the attraction. His liability is said to bear a relation to the charactor of the thing, whether natural and common, or artificial and uncommon, and to the comparative ease or difficulty of preventing the danger without destroying the usefulness of the thing. Liability attaches only when the contrivance is novel in character, and is of such a nature as to virtually constitute a trap into which children, because of their ignorance and inexperience, are led, for it is the duty of parents to warn their children, and children are presumed to know, of common dangers existing in the order of nature. . . . It is an essential ingredient of an action based upon the attractive nuisance doctrine that a child should be attracted to the premise by a natural curiosity and desire to play upon or with the contrivance. . . . However, liability is not imposed in all cases merely because a thing is attractive to children; it must also be novel in character, dangerous, easily guarded and rendered safe, and the one having control of the apparatus must be under an affirmative duty to prevent children from playing thereon. It is for the jury to determine whether an instrumentality is attractive to children, and whether or not an owner is obliged to guard against injuries to trespassing children." And further: "In order that an owner of an attractive and dangerous instrumentality be held liable it must be shown that he knows, or as a reasonably prudent man ought to know, of the dangerous character of the contrivance. . . . The attractive nuisance doctrine applies only where the instrumentality which causes the injury is some novel and dangerous appliance, the consequences of meddling with which are not fully comprehended by infant minds." All of these propositions involve questions of fact as well as of law. Thus, it is for the jury to determine whether the instrumentality is attractive to children. It is likewise a question of fact whether the danger could have been easily guarded against. It is also a question of fact whether the method of construction was new or novel, and a question of fact whether *Page 349
the spikes placed upon the pole in question, from a few inches above the ground to the top thereof, constituted a virtual invitation to boys to climb thereon; and it is a question of fact, also, as to whether the defendant ought to have reasonably anticipated the danger of making it readily accessible for boys to climb up the pole in question. The rule in this particular we think applies to the present case just as in the case of Cahill
v. Stone Co.,
In the case of Nicolosi v. Clark,
In Wallace v. Great Western Power Co.,
[2] In the instant case it is conceded that the spikes or steps upon which one might climb in ascending the pole were maintained in contravention of a rule or regulation or order of the Railroad Commission. Such act constitutes negligence perse.
In the case of Howell v. San Joaquin Light Power Co.,
In the case of Minter v. San Diego Cons. Gas Elec. Co.,
The facts in the case of Howard v. Transmission Co., 316 Mo. 317 [49 A.L.R. 1034,
In the case of State v. Trimble, 316 Mo. 32 [49 A.L.R. 1047,
In the case of Reddy v. City of Watertown,
As against the authorities relied upon by the appellant are several well-considered cases which we think establish the true rule, especially in view of the fact that the act of the defendant in violating General Order No. 64-A of the Railroad *Page 353 Commission must be held negligence per se, which distinguishes the questions we are considering upon this appeal from the cases relied upon by the appellant.
In Robertson v. Rockland Light Power Co.,
In Znidersich v. Minnesota Utilities Co.,
In McKiddy v. Des Moines Elec. Co., 202 Iowa, 225 [
Again, in Talkington v. Washington W. P. Co.,
In the recent case of Cooper v. North Coast Power Co.,
Again, the case of Robertson v. Rockland Light Power Co.,supra, shows that the teacher of the school where the injured boy attended, had warned the children of the danger of coming in contact with the wires, and had warned them not to climb the pole. Nevertheless, it was a question of fact for the jury as to whether the injured boy understood the danger to which he was exposed. In the Parkes case, supra, had the telephone wire been a high-power electric wire, it would have been a fact for the jury whether the company should have been charged with knowledge, or should have been held to have reasonably anticipated that children would climb the pole and come in contact with the death-dealing current. It was the boy's voluntary act in that case which caused his injury, and not the negligent maintenance of conditions which might allure a small child to come in contact with a wire carrying a high voltage of electricity.
In Heller v. New York, N.H. H. Ry. Co., 265 Fed. 192 [17 A.L.R. 823], a case relied upon by the appellant, the circumstances show that it could not have been reasonably anticipated by the defendant that boys would climb to the heights which was done in that case, and come in contact with an electric wire.
In Stedwell v. City of Chicago,
In Thompson v. City of Slater, 197 Mo. App. 247 [193 S.W. 971], an eight year old boy was injured by coming in contact with an uninsulated wire extending through a tree, when the limb above the wires upon which the boy was sitting broke, causing him to come in contact with one of the wires.
In Benton v. North Carolina Public-Service Co.,
In Wolfe v. Ford,
Appellant calls our attention to the case of Bradley v.Thompson,
From what we have said it clearly appears that both the Reddy and Trimble cases, supra, are against the great weight of authority and are furthermore readily distinguishable from the case at bar in that the violation of no order, *Page 358 ordinance or statute regulating the construction of electric power lines was involved. Again, it must be presumed that the defendant had knowledge of General Order No. 64-A of the Railroad Commission, which imparted knowledge of the fact of the inherent danger of placing spikes or steps upon poles carrying high-power electric lines, and of the allurement that would thereby be created for children with propensity to climb.
Appellant further urges as ground of reversal the refusal of the court to give certain requested instructions, and also in giving certain instructions. As to the instructions asked for by the defendant and refused, it is sufficient to say that most of them are not correct statements of the law, and in so far as they contain correct statements of the law, they are covered by the instructions given by the court to the jury. Particular objection is made to the following instruction, to wit: "The right of the plaintiff to recover damages in this case is dependent upon the negligence of the defendant. The negligence of the defendant if any, may be either the acts or omissions of the defendant or its agents and servants while in the course of their employment, or a violation of a statute, rule or ordinance which proximately caused the injury, if any, complained of. Proximate cause is that cause which in natural and continuous sequence, unbroken by any efficient intervening cause, produces injury and without which, the injury would not have occurred. The efficient cause mentioned above is the one that necessarily sets the other cause in motion; the cause without which an injury would not have occurred. If the defendant was negligent, either through the acts and conduct of itself, its employees or its agents in the course of agency and employment or by violation of a rule of the Railroad Commission, and such negligence was the proximate cause of the injury to plaintiff, then plaintiff is entitled to recover for the injury sustained, if any." The contention being that no reference is made in this instruction, to the contributory negligence of the plaintiff.
[3] Objection is also made to instruction No. 20, which reads: "I instruct you that if you find that defendant violated General Order No. 64-A of the Railroad Commission and that such violation thereof proximately caused the injury, and that the doctrine of attractive nuisance applies as *Page 359 herein instructed thereon, and that plaintiff exercised such care as an ordinary child of like years would under like circumstances, then I instruct you plaintiff is entitled to a verdict for damages at your hands, if he has suffered injury."
Instruction No. 23 told the jury that the child involved in this action was bound to exercise such care as children of his age would ordinarily exercise; and further, that if the jury found from the evidence that at the time Murray Clark climbed the pole, he knew of the danger attendant upon contact with the wires thereon, the verdict should be for the defendant.
The court further instructed the jury that if it found that Murray Clark failed to exercise the care of an ordinarily prudent boy of his age and experience, under the same or similar circumstances, in climbing the pole and bringing himself in contact with the wires, and that if the plaintiff exercised such care he would not have been injured by contact with the wires, that the verdict should be for the defendant.
The cases which we have cited heretofore in this opinion relative to the law applicable, show that the instructions given to the jury are in strict accord therewith, and do not require further consideration.
[4] Some contention is also made that counsel for the plaintiff was guilty of prejudicial misconduct in his opening statement. The length of this opinion already precludes any detailed mention of this objection. It was a reference to, in substance, the wealth of the corporation and the poverty of the plaintiff, the court promptly stating that testimony to that effect was inadmissible, and no testimony was offered.
While there is some conflict in the cases cited, we think that the weight of authority supports the judgment in this case, based upon the fact that an unseen danger, the presence of which can only be ascertained by an act which renders knowledge of its presence of no avail, demands great care and caution on the part of those maintaining such instrumentalities in order that the lives of children may not be destroyed. A consideration of the injuries sustained by the plaintiff, without reciting them, shows that the verdict is not excessive. *Page 360
The order denying defendant's motion for judgment, notwithstanding the verdict, and the judgment are affirmed.
Preston, P.J., and Thompson (R.L.), J., concurred.
A petition for a rehearing of this cause was denied by the District Court of Appeal on December 16, 1931, and the following opinion rendered thereon:
THE COURT.
[5] Appellant again contends that there was no testimony showing the date of the construction of the pole involved in this action, and therefore that General Order 64-A of the Railroad Commission did not apply, and that the trial court and this court were both in error in assuming that it did.
A consideration of the pleadings which was given in the first instance, and are now referred to, shows that the appellant's contention is untenable, as only one question in relation to the pole was tendered, to wit: Whether the steps on the pole were lower than 7 feet, and were down to within 3 feet of the ground. The allegations of the complaint in paragraph IV are as follows: "That said defendant caused steps to be maintained on said poles from the top to within 3 feet of the ground, the first step being less than 3 feet, contrary to General Order 64-A of the Railroad Commission and contrary to all rules of safety and carefulness; that General Order 64-A, effective March 1, 1929, issued by the Railroad Commission, provides that for any overhead line constructed conducting electricity, the lowest step on any step-pole shall not be less than 7 feet 6 inches from the ground, and a space between steps on the same side of the pole shall not exceed 36 inches, which said General Order or rule was well known to the defendant herein." The appellant's answer reads as follows: "Answering the allegations contained in Paragraph IV of the plaintiff's first cause of action, said defendant denies that it caused steps to be maintained on any part of said pole from the top to within 3 feet of the ground, and in this connection defendant alleges that the lowest step on each of said poles was placed and maintained at least 7 feet above the ground and in substantial compliance *Page 361 with the said General Order 64-A of the Railroad Commission referred to in said complaint."
It will thus be seen that no issue was tendered by the denials of the appellant as to the application of General Order 64-A of the Railroad Commission, and the only testimony required on the part of the plaintiff was to show that the steps on the pole came down below the prohibited distance from the ground, and within 3 feet thereof, as alleged.
The petition for rehearing is denied.
A petition by appellant to have the cause heard in the Supreme Court, after judgment in the District Court of Appeal, was denied by the Supreme Court on January 14, 1932.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.