People v. Neal CA1/2
Opinion
Filed 9/10/26 P. v. Neal CA1/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION TWO THE PEOPLE,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
A172377 v. THOMAS NEAL, (San Francisco County
Super. Ct. No. CRI-22001617) Defendant and Appellant.
In March 2022, in San Francisco Superior Court, Thomas Neal pled guilty to felony assault with a deadly weapon and admitted an allegation of great bodily injury. The trial court imposed a five-year state prison term but suspended execution of sentence and granted Neal probation with a referral to the Veterans Justice Court (VJC). However, in July 2023, Neal’s probation was violated in connection with his alleged commission in San Joaquin County of another assault with a deadly weapon. Neal was separately prosecuted in San Joaquin County and ultimately committed to state prison. In March 2024, while imprisoned, Neal demanded “a hearing and trial” in the San Francisco action under Penal Code, section 13811 that resulted in his April 2024 transfer to San Francisco Superior Court. Neal was referred back to VJC while his probation violation remained pending. After months of court appearances and continuances, an evidentiary hearing was held in October 2024, and Neal was found to have violated his probation. Thereafter, Neal moved to dismiss the San Francisco action, arguing the court had lost jurisdiction to execute the previously suspended sentence by failing to issue its commitment order within the time constraints of section 1203.2a.2 The court denied the motion and ordered Neal to serve the remainder of his original five-year sentence consecutive to his San Joaquin County commitment.
Neal now appeals under the same statute but with an alternative argument. We are not persuaded and affirm the court’s order.
BACKGROUND
I. The Cases in San Francisco and San Joaquin Counties3 On December 24, 2021, Neal was arrested in San Francisco after a
“road rage incident” during which Neal purportedly threw a tire iron at another car’s rear window, shattering it. When the driver of the other car exited his vehicle and confronted Neal, Neal threatened, “ ‘You don’t want to sentenced, and imprisoned in one case while there is another pending criminal proceeding “wherein the defendant remains to be sentenced.”
On February 15, 2022, San Francisco police officers were alerted to a stabbing after a possible “hit and run.” Surveillance footage showed Neal walking towards a dark SUV and speaking with someone inside the vehicle. Neal opened the car’s rear doors, and the victim crawled out of the back driver’s side door and limped across the street. Neal retrieved a metal pole from the vehicle and followed the victim, striking him “on the leg, three times on the head, and once in [his] left side” before Neal returned to his own car and fled. The video also showed Neal wearing a knife with a sheath on his hip. When Neal was stopped later that morning, officers discovered dried blood in the rear seat of his vehicle and “three knives, a knife sharpener, a metal pole, and another knife in a backpack.”
The two incidents served as a basis for a felony complaint filed in February 2022, and in March, Neal entered into a negotiated disposition in which he pled guilty to felony assault with a deadly weapon (§ 245, subd. (a)(1); count 1) and admitted an allegation of great bodily injury (§ 12022.7, subd. (a)). Subject to a Harvey4 waiver, the remaining charges were dismissed, as was an unrelated case from 2020 in which Neal was alleged to have threatened a restaurant worker with a knife but had been placed on pretrial division. In April 2022, the court sentenced Neal to five years in state prison but suspended execution of the sentence pending his successful completion of two years of probation, during which Neal was
In November 2022, Neal failed to appear for a scheduled VJC hearing after being discharged from his residential program, and a bench warrant issued.
The night of May 31, 2023, Neal was reported as the assailant in an “unprovoked” assault in San Joaquin County with “a weapon known as a ‘monkey fist’ described as a ‘ball on a chain.’ ” The victim had been talking with a friend with his two minor children present when Neal hit him “with the slung shot at least three times, once in the head, upper left back, and right ear,” causing “moderate injuries.” Neal “walked away” from the scene after the victim told somebody to call the police. A Ramey5 warrant for Neal’s arrest issued the next day.
In June 2023, Neal was arrested and remanded to the custody of the San Francisco County Sheriff’s Department pending his appearance in VJC for possible placement.6 For the next several weeks, Neal continued to appear in VJC pending placement.
However, in July 2023, having learned Neal was “named as a suspect in a felony assault” in San Joaquin County, the San Francisco County District Attorney filed a motion to revoke his probation.7 Neal continued to
Neal remained in custody in San Joaquin County until December 2023, when he was convicted of felony assault with force likely to produce great bodily injury (§ 245, subd. (a)(4)), felony possession of a slungshot (§ 22210), and misdemeanor child endangerment (§ 273a, subd. (a)) and was sentenced to two years in state prison.
On March 7, 2024, while serving his sentence in the San Joaquin case in San Quentin State Prison, Neal filed a “Notice and Demand for Trial” with the San Francisco County District Attorney pursuant to section 1381. The form represented that Neal had been convicted and sentenced in San Joaquin County to two years in state prison with a “Tentative Release Date/Minimum Eligible Parole Date” of July 24, 2024. It further stated that Neal had “reason to believe” he had a pending criminal action in San Francisco for a violation of section 245, subdivision (a)(1) under warrant No. 836103—the bench warrant issued in connection with his motion to revoke probation—and therefore demanded “a hearing and trial of said criminal action as prescribed by section 1381 of the California Penal Code.” (Capitalization omitted.)
On March 22, 2024, the San Francisco County District Attorney requested and the court ordered Neal transferred to San Francisco County Jail pursuant to his section 1381 demand and for an April 10 hearing. On April 10, Neal’s bench warrant was discharged with a finding of “[n]o . . . contempt”; he was remanded to the custody of the San Francisco County Sheriff’s Department, and a further hearing was set for April 17, 2024.
At the April 17 hearing “To Set Motion to Revoke Probation,” Neal’s attorney represented, “What [Neal] really, really wants to do is deal with these cases in [VJC] rather than being sentenced.” He stated that Neal’s San Quentin commitment was “over,” and Neal “used the 1381 as a vehicle to get here. I don’t think he is actually seeking to be sentenced on a five-year ESS.”8 Counsel explained, “it is really not a 1381 because it is a probation case.” When the district attorney insisted on setting a June 17, 2024, deadline for hearing on Neal’s section 1381 demand, Neal’s attorney asserted, “There is no ticking clock” and “There shouldn’t be a last day.” The court agreed, “I don’t think there is a last day either,” but set the June 17 deadline and referred Neal to VJC as his attorney had requested.
At the conclusion of the April 17 hearing, the probation officer present informed the court that “[a]ccording to [the] case notes” from an April 9 VJC hearing, the probation department had recommended terminating Neal from VJC in favor of proceeding on his motion to revoke probation and had also “provided the court with an updated status on [Neal] serving his prison term in San Quentin.”9
The matter was continued to April 19, 2024, and then again to May 3, to secure “a copy of the [presentence report]” and “any information on the status of [Neal’s] custody and his term at San Quentin and the underlying allegations that are the basis of this motion to revoke.” No new report was prepared, so, on May 3, the court continued the matter to May 17, directing the probation department file a “short supplemental report” in the interim.
The short supplemental report filed on May 17 detailed Neal’s criminal history, including his San Joaquin County conviction for which Neal had been sentenced to two years in prison, and represented Neal “is currently in the custody of the California Department of Corrections [and Rehabilitation] and is expected to be released to Parole in July of 2024.” At the May 17 hearing, Neal’s attorney requested a two-week continuance, which the court granted, setting the matter for May 31, 2023, when the motion to revoke probation was again continued. According to the record provided on appeal, the matter was scheduled “To Set” seven additional times before an evidentiary hearing was held on the motion to revoke probation on October 4, 2024.10
At the start of the October 4 hearing, Neal’s defense attorney represented “to preserve that argument for appeal” that even though the 90- day deadline under section 1381 “would have been June 17 of 2024,” he had not moved to dismiss the action because “the DA . . . cited [Boles v. Superior Court (1974) 37 Cal.App.3d 479, 484]. And it does say that 1381 does not apply when execution of sentence is suspended, as opposed to imposition of sentence suspended, which under People v. Wagner -- which is a 2009 California [Supreme] Court case, 45 Cal.4th 1039. It says when it is imposition of sentence suspended that a 1381 demand should be honored, or has to be honored under the law.”
After the submission of evidence, the court found by a “preponderance of the evidence that . . . Neal committed a willful violation of the terms of his probation” because of his December 2023 conviction in San Joaquin County and his failure to report to probation and to complete VJC. Regarding sentencing, the court explained what it was “most concerned about” and “most interested in” was “what are the proper credits? And whether and to what extent Mr. Neal would be entitled to credits while he was in custody in other jurisdictions.” Neal’s counsel clarified his position: “[I]t’s not that Mr. Neal is entitled to credits, it’s about whether he should be given concurrent versus consecutive time. And whether -- my argument is, just because he did a 1381 demand as opposed to 1203.2(a) shouldn’t be the dividing line. Because they’re both, essentially, requesting the same thing, that he be sentenced and that he was in [California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation], and so he should ask for concurrent time.”
The court set a briefing schedule, and on October 17, 2024, Neal moved to dismiss the probation revocation proceedings under section 1203.2a because the court was “divested of jurisdiction,” or in the alternative, requested probation be reinstated. Neal’s motion to dismiss argued “all three jurisdictional clocks discussed in Hoddinott have been violated” based on the probation department’s knowledge of Neal’s December 2023 prison commitment, the triggering section 1381 demand from March 2024, and the court’s failure to sentence Neal within 60 days of his return to San Francisco on March 22, 2024.
On December 6, 2024, Neal filed a supplemental motion citing additional authority and emphasizing the purpose of statutes such as sections 1381 and 1203.2a was “to permit a defendant to obtain concurrent sentencing.” He also analogized his case to In re Mancillas (2016) 2 Cal.App.5th 896 (Mancillas), arguing the court lost jurisdiction under section 1203.2a because it had failed to sentence Neal within 60 days of his section 1381 demand.
The People opposed the motions, arguing that “Because [Neal] never asserted his right under Penal Code section 1203.2a to serve his suspended sentence in the instant matter concurrently with his prison time on an unrelated conviction, [Neal] does not qualify for the remedy of dismissal of the instant matter that [he] invokes under section 1203.2a.” The People further contended that Mancillas did not apply because Neal had not sent his demand to the court and requested to be sentenced in absentia, he had sent a section 1381 demand to the district attorney, and thus, no section 1203.2a jurisdictional clock was triggered. Moreover, they claimed that because Neal had asserted his rights under section 1381, he forfeited his rights under section 1203.2a.
On January 3, 2025, after a chambers discussion, the court orally issued a tentative ruling denying Neal’s motion to dismiss in view of the First District case of People v. Hall (1997) 59 Cal.App.4th 972 (Hall), and noted the need for “a triggering event, and that is the court needs to have strict notice of -- that the -- that the defendant was incarcerated . . . . [¶] And that is notice from the probation officer or notice from a warden . . . of the prison in which there was incarceration that defendant was incarcerated on another offense. Absent those triggering events, the 60-day doesn’t begin to elapse.”
The court agreed with the district attorney that the section “1381 demand . . . is inconsistent with the now request from the defense that the court should have summarily imposed the ESS notwithstanding their request that the matter be contested and heard” and reminded Neal’s counsel that “in terms of sentencing that you agreed that the sentencing could be put over so that these matters could be briefed . . . .” Neal’s counsel countered, arguing that the triggering event was either the March 2024 section 1381 demand or, alternatively, the October 2024 probation revocation hearing, both of which preceded the sentencing hearing by more than 60 days. Defense counsel acknowledged, “I didn’t bring up these issues on the date of the hearing because I wasn’t aware of them” “at the date of the hearing” but still asserted, “it doesn’t matter. I -- the jurisdictional clock is the jurisdictional clock. It’s not something that we waive by agreeing to more time. It’s not . . . anything like that. It’s a clock. . . . [¶] [M]y position is it started well before the hearing because Your Honor was aware, prosecution was aware, and I was aware that Mr. Neal was incarcerated, committed to state prison on another offense, far before the hearing.”
The court clarified that section 1203.2 is “not based on constructive knowledge. It’s not even based on actual knowledge. It’s based on notice, statutory notice.” To which Neal’s attorney responded, “Sure.” Finding “that didn’t occur,” the court asked counsel, “if your position is true that . . . the court should impose all ESSs once it has constructive notice that somebody is incarcerated, notwithstanding that the defendant may not want . . . that ESS imposed until they have an opportunity to be heard . . . whether the People know about it, whether anybody else knows about it -- if the court has constructive knowledge of that, then that 60 days . . . starts to run. [¶] And even though it contradicts . . . how the parties want to proceed.” Neal’s attorney responded, “And the point of the 1203.2 . . . is someone doesn’t have the right to even be present. It’s supposed to happen in absentia. . . . [I]t’s not what I think should happen; it’s just what the law is, that that is a jurisdictional clock when it comes to an ESS.”
The court concluded, “I think as a practical matter it would be very dangerous if . . . a jurisdictional clock begins to run based on inferences that can be drawn from pleadings without meeting . . . what the statute defines as notice to a court. [¶] So I deny the motion to dismiss on that ground.” The court then heard the parties’ arguments on sentencing, after which it ordered the execution of Neal’s previously suspended five-year sentence and that it run consecutively to his San Joaquin County commitment.
Neal timely appeals.
DISCUSSION
On appeal, Neal’s argument has shifted.11 Although he still relies on section 1203.2a, he now contends the 60-day jurisdictional clock under section 1203.2a was triggered by: (1) the oral notice of Neal’s custody status that the probation department provided the VJC court on April 9, 2024; and (2) the reference to Neal’s San Joaquin County prison commitment in the short supplemental report filed by the probation department on May 17, 2024. We disagree and conclude neither “notice” triggered section 1203.2a’s jurisdictional clock, and, even if triggered, Neal’s conduct waived any potentially applicable time limitations.
I. Applicable Law
Section 1203.2a permits a defendant who is on probation and is later committed to prison on another offense to ask the original sentencing court to
Under section 1203.2a, in exchange for giving up the right to counsel, a petitioning probationer gains, “the right to obtain sentencing more quickly than under . . . section 1381, and the right to have any term of imprisonment imposed thereunder ‘commence upon the date upon which defendant was delivered to prison under commitment for his or her subsequent offense.’ ” (Wagner, supra, 45 Cal.4th at p. 1054.) But, because pronouncing judgment
Once a triggering notice has been adequately made, “section 1203.2a provides for 3 distinct jurisdictional clocks: (1) the probation officer has 30 days from the receipt of written notice [from defendant] of defendant’s subsequent commitment within which to notify the probation-granting court [citation]; (2) the court has 30 days from the receipt of a valid, formal request from defendant within which to impose sentence, if sentence has not previously been imposed [citation]; and (3) the court has 60 days from the receipt of notice of the confinement to order execution of sentence (or make other final order) if sentence has previously been imposed [citation].”13 (Hoddinott, supra, 12 Cal.4th at p. 999.) “Failure to comply with any one of
Here, there is no dispute Neal’s original San Francisco sentence had already been imposed with its execution suspended, thus, our analysis is limited to the third jurisdictional clock.15 (See, e.g., Mancillas, supra, 2 Cal.App.5th at pp. 906, 910 [section 1203.2a’s third jurisdictional clock is applied where execution of sentence has been suspended and the defendant placed on probation]; Wagner, supra, 45 Cal.4th at p. 1050 [section 1203.2a “provides one set of procedures for probation with the imposition of sentence suspended and other procedures for probation with the execution of sentence suspended”].)
II. Triggering Notice
As stated, Neal now contends that section 1203.2a’s third jurisdictional clock was triggered by: (1) oral notice the probation department provided the VJC on April 9, 2024; and (2) the short supplemental report filed by the probation department on or around May 17, 2024. He argues the trial court’s failure to “execute the previously suspended sentence within 60 days of probation’s notification to the court of Neal’s imprisonment for the unrelated assault” divests it of jurisdiction. In response, the Attorney General asserts
Section 1203.2a, which is “not a model of clarity” (Murray, supra, 155 Cal.App.4th at p. 154),17 does not explicitly specify the form or content of a triggering notice, but it appears to require a specific written demand from a defendant or his counsel or a duly authorized representative of the warden or of the prison where the defendant is housed that also represents the nature of his commitment and his desire for speedy sentencing in absentia. (§ 1203.2a.)
For example, in Murray, at appellant’s request, the CDCR submitted a letter to the probation department advising of the appellant’s CDCR
Following similar logic, in Hall, the defendant probationer was alleged to have committed a new offense, which led the probation department to file with the court a “ ‘Notice of Probation Violation and Court Action’ ” that detailed the defendant’s arrest and said, “ ‘He was transferred to the California Institut[e] for Men at Chino the same date.’ ” (Hall, supra, 59 Cal.App.4th at p. 978.) The following year, the probation department filed an amended notice which listed an additional probation violation based on the defendant pleading “ ‘guilty to a new violation . . . resulting from an arrest in Long Beach, California . . . .’ ” (Ibid.) Shortly before the filing of the amended notice of probation violation, the defendant had served on the district attorney in his probationary county a demand for hearing and trial pursuant to section 1381, and seven months later, he filed with the court a motion to dismiss for failing to comply with section 1381. (Hall, at p. 978.) In opposition to the motion to dismiss, the district attorney asserted section 1381 did not apply to the defendant who was on probation (like Neal) but noted that “if the court deemed appellant’s motion to dismiss a request to be sentenced under section 1203.2a, then appellant must be sentenced within 60 days . . . .” (Hall, at p. 978.) The court held the probation violation hearing within 60 days and ordered execution of the previously imposed but stayed sentence the following month. (Id. at pp. 978–979.)
On appeal, Division Two of the First District rejected Hall’s contention that the court had lost jurisdiction to order execution of sentence, concluding that neither notice of probation violation triggered section 1203.2a’s jurisdictional clock because they “did not inform the court that appellant had been committed to prison for another offense and thus did not qualify under the statute.” (Hall, supra, 59 Cal.App.4th at p. 984.) Similarly, the defendant probationer’s motion to dismiss for violation of section 1381 “did not trigger the court’s 60-day jurisdictional clock” because, “To qualify under paragraph three of section 1203.2a, the notice must be from the probation officer or from the warden or other duly authorized representative of any prison. There is no provision for notice from a defendant to the court.” (Hall, at p. 984.) Therefore, “Under the rule requiring strict compliance with the statute,” the Court of Appeal held “appellant’s April 22 motion insufficient to invoke the 60-day jurisdictional time limit set forth in the third paragraph of section 1203.2a.” (Ibid.)
Neal’s citation to Mancillas does not warrant a different conclusion. Mancillas involved a probationer who was subsequently convicted of a new offense out-of-state. (Mancillas, supra, 2 Cal.App.5th at p. 901.) While serving his sentence, petitioner asked prison officials “ ‘for the appropriate forms’ ” to request sentencing on his California cases and was provided with and completed an eight-page packet entitled “ ‘Interstate Agreement on Detainers,’ ” which included an “ ‘Inmate’s Notice of Place of Imprisonment and Request for Disposition of Indictments, Informations or Complaints’ ” and a “ ‘Certificate of Inmate Status.’ ” (Ibid.) In the forms, petitioner requested “ ‘final disposition be made’ ” of his two California cases and included information about his name, location, out-of-state sentence, and California case numbers. (Ibid.) The forms were signed by petitioner, two correctional officers, and the warrants coordinator and were sent to the trial court and the district attorney’s office of the probationary county. (Id. at pp. 901–902.) No action was taken, and approximately nine months later, the probation department in California reported to the court that it had received an e-mail from petitioner’s trial counsel including notification of the out-of-state incarceration and requesting that petitioner be sentenced pursuant to section 1203.2a. (Mancillas, at pp. 902–903.) Within 60 days, the court ordered execution of the petitioner’s stayed prison sentence without requiring an admission of the probation violation. (Id. at p. 903.) The Court of Appeal subsequently declared the execution of sentence void for lack of jurisdiction, as the original demand from the out-of-state department of corrections had complied with section 1203.2a’s third prong and triggered the jurisdictional clock. (Mancillas, at pp. 906, 910–911.)
Here, unlike the above cases, we do not have a triggering section 1203.2a demand from Neal or from a correctional facility. Instead, Neal now argues that the purported April 2024 oral representation by a probation officer in VJC that Neal was incarcerated for the San Joaquin offense qualified as a 1203.2a demand, or, in the alternative, the probation department’s reference to Neal’s San Joaquin-related incarceration in its May 2024 short supplemental report triggered the 60-day jurisdictional timeclock.
But an oral statement from a probation officer—particularly one not included in the record on appeal—is not sufficient to provide notice under section 1203.2a, which requires strict compliance. (Pompi v. Superior Court (1982) 139 Cal.App.3d 503, 507 [“in the absence of a defendant’s strict compliance with the statutory requirements [of section 1203.2a], no ouster of jurisdiction will result”].)
And the single sentence reference in the seven-page short supplemental report stating that Neal had been convicted of the San Joaquin offense and was “currently in the custody of the [CDCR] and is expected to be released to Parole in July of 2024,” cannot trigger section 1203.2a’s jurisdictional timeclock when it neither references the statute by name nor in any way indicates that Neal wished to waive his rights to counsel and to appear in court and instead wanted his previously suspended sentence ordered executed immediately, in absentia. (See Wagner, supra, 45 Cal.4th at p. 1054 [“ ‘[R]equests for sentencing pursuant to section 1203.2a must be in strict compliance with that section. [Citations.] . . . [I]f the court pronounces judgment in the absence of such a request and waiver, it violates the defendant’s constitutional rights to have the assistance of and to be personally present with counsel’ ”].)
Moreover, to the extent either statement by the probation department might be considered to be a triggering demand under section 1203.2a, Neal’s conduct has waived any associated timeclock. (People v. Martinez (1975) 46 Cal.App.3d 736, 740, fn. 1, 742 [the time limitations of section 1203.2a “may, of course, be waived”; a defendant’s request of the court to “ ‘make disposition of my probation as required by law’ ” is “not the same as requesting the court to ‘impose sentence’ ”].) At the time Neal now asserts he was demanding the execution of his suspended San Francisco County prison commitment, the record shows directly contrary conduct, which involved months of represented court appearances where Neal and his attorney repeatedly sought readmission into VJC and Behavioral Health Court. (People v. Davidson (1972) 25 Cal.App.3d 79, 85 [the “record makes it unmistakable that . . . appellant personally and through his counsel waived any sentencing requirement that might have been applicable by Penal Code, section 1203.2a”].)
Moreover, Neal’s counsel repeatedly represented to the court, “There is no ticking clock”; “There shouldn’t be a last day.” And explained in direct contradiction to a section 1203.2a demand, “I don’t think he is actually seeking to be sentenced on a five-year ESS.” Neal cannot now fault the court’s acceptance of his own representations. (See People v. Midell (2025) 113 Cal.App.5th 1060, 1072 [“ ‘ “[W]hen a party by its own conduct induces the commission of error, it may not claim on appeal that the judgment should be reversed because of that error” ’ ”].) Indeed, had the court separately ordered Neal’s sentence executed under section 1203.2a despite his multiple appearances with counsel requesting sentencing alternatives, such an order would likely have amounted to constitutional error our Supreme Court warned against in Wagner. (Wagner, supra, 45 Cal.4th at p. 1054.)
Accordingly, neither mention of Neal’s San Joaquin commitment by the probation department qualified as “notice” triggering section 1203.2a’s jurisdictional clock,18 and even if interpreted as a demand under section 1203.2a, Neal’s conduct waived any associated time limits.
DISPOSITION
The trial court’s January 3, 2025 commitment order lifting the stay of execution of Neal’s five-year sentence imposed on April 19, 2022, is affirmed. reference to section 1203.2a. (People v. Martinez, supra, 46 Cal.App.3d at p. 742; People v. Davidson, supra, 25 Cal.App.3d at p. 85.)
DESAUTELS, J.
We concur:
STEWART, P. J.
RICHMAN, J.
People v. Neal (A172377)
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.