JS-6 1 II.RELEVANPTR IOHRI STORY 2 Ono ra boNuotv em6b,2e 0r1 P9e,t itfiiloeanPd ee rt ifotriW orniot fH abeas 3 Corp[uDsk.Nt o.1. ] A.l thofaurfrg ohmt hmeo doefcl l artihPteey t,i rtaiiossnee vse ral 4 clacihmasl levnagriianosgup seo cfPt est iticoonnedrio'tfcsi o onnfisn em[eIndTt.h.]e .

5 Petisteifotorsnt fi hv ger oufonrdr se laisfoe lfl,o ws: 6 1. "Retaliatciaonufo/sriea mscp tlaiigoeandi p nlsatif notlrie ffgs auli ts;" 7 2. "Crauneudln uspuuanli shbmyce onrtp aonrcdaa lp idteaplr ivation;" 8 3. "Faitlopu rroetfr eocmht a romfr etaloifea mtpiloonay neiden sm ates;" 9 4. "Entraopffam lesrneut l veiso larteipootnroist m sp ousnen ecetsismaer y 10 creldoistas n;d" 11 5. "Obstroufoc uttigoaonni idnn gc omliengmgaa lia lc tiboycn esn sorship." 12 [DkNto.1.p , p 5.- 6]. 13 Petitfuirotnhaeelrrl e"gTeassA,hl afa rEos,qL .e,Ce l ark,a nPEdrs iqLs.ao,wn 14 Officfael siemlpye rspolnaaitinenat bisffe n[tIipda.7.. ],". 15 Ina ddittoti hoienn staacnttiP oent,i thiaofisnl eefirdvo et hfeedre rhaalb eas

16 petiatnitdow nesn tfey-doenrceai lrv iiglah cttsii ontn hsCi osu rSteC.ea sNeo s1.9 - 17 005P8S G( ADS); P1S9G-( 0A6D5S10)9 ;- 0P8S7G8 (ADS)P;S G(1 A9D-S11)91;-8 8 18 165P0S G( ADS1)8;- 2P5S9G(5 A DS1)9;- 0P0S2G(2 A DS1)9;- 0P0S8G(5 A DS1)9;- 19 008P7S G( ADS1)9;- 0P0S9G(3 A DS1)9;4-5 40P SG( ADS1)9;- 0P5S8G(7 A DS1)9;- 20 060P7S G( ADS1)9;- 0P6S9G(9 A DS1)9;- 0P7S5G(0 A DS1)9;- 076(8A DPS1S)9G;- 21 accucraancnyo t rebaeqs uoensatbiloUynn eidt.e"d)v ;W.S i tlastoensF, . 216d13 1811, 9 22 (9th Cir.c o1u9mr8at0yt ) a jk(ue"d [inAco]it aoilfic teos wn r ecoirnod tshc ears aess , wealsl the orfae nic noferrcdiosou irrno t t hcears eHsa.r"vr)C.i;ty s o. fO ran6g8e2, 23 F.31d1 2161,3( 29 tChi2 r0.1 (2h)o ltdhiaanc tgo umratyt ajkued incoitaoilfc e undispmuattetodefp r usb rleicco rd). 24 1 076P9S (GA DS1)9;- 0P7S7(G4A DS1)9;- 0P7S7(G6A DS1)9;- 0P7S8(G2A DS1)9;- 2 078P3S (GA DS1)9;- 0P7S8(G6A DS); P1S9(G-A 0D7S19)91;- 1P1S4(G9A DS1)9;- 3 013P9S7(G A DS1)9;- 0P1S6(G5A 1D SF)u.r thears meoarorenc, h P ArCeEvRet ahlast 4 Petithiamosun letrfei dpelraeac lt ipoennsdi inon tghD eirs tCroiucirtnCts as l ifornia. 5 SePeA CEwwRw,. pa.gcoevr.

6 IIID.ISCUSSION 7 A. FailtuoSr tea atC eo gnizaCbllaei m 8 ThCeo uhratts h aeu thtoord iitsymh iasbsea acst isousnaps o nUtned.Re url4 e 9 oft hReu lGeosv er§n2 i2n5Cg4a sieifspt ,l aianplpyefr aormts h pee tiatniadon ny 10 attaecxhheidtb hitathtpse e titiinsoo entne tri ttorl eel"dit echfoe,u m rutss tu mmarily 11d ismtihpsees t iwtiitohonor udte arr iensgp onsiveM apyvllF.eee a ld5ii4xnU5,g. .S". 12 6446,5( 62 00s5ea)el; Ps aogt alvuG.na alna2 z9Fa1., 36 d3 96,4n 1.,(1 9 Ctih2r 0.0 2) 13( quoti4n)gS. u Rmumladeri ys miosfah s aablep aesti itasip opnr opwrhietarhteee 14a llegiantt hipeoe ntsia trvieao gnou rce o nclpuaslopriaynb,cl rye odrpi abtleen,t ly 15fr ivoolrfao lussHe e.n drviV.ca kssq 9u0eF8z. ,24 d9 04,9(19 Ctih1r 9.9 (0q)u oting 16 BlackvlA.el dlgi4es3 oU1n. 6S,3. 7, 5 -(7169 7U7n)d)Te.ir t2 l8Ue . SS.eCc.t2 i2o5an4 ,

17fe dercaolus rhtae lnlt earnta apipnl ifocraw trioiofhtn a becaosr p"uosno lnty h ger ound 18 th[atth e peitisinc t uisotinonved iryo] l oaftt hiCeoo nn stiotrlu atwoisrto rne aotfi es 19t hUen iStteadt 2e8Us ..S"§. 2 C2.5 4H(aab)e.ca osr ppruosc eeadrtiehn pegr so per 20 mechafonric shma lltehneg ilnoegrdg uarlaiottfciy oo nnfi newmheianlc tei rviiglh ts 21a ctiitsoh npe r ompeert htoocd h allceonngdeio tfci oonnfisn eBmaednvetC.a.o x9,3 1 22 F.25d75 37,(4 9 Ctih1r 9.9 1). 23 HertehC,eo uhratss c retehnieen ds tPaentti tifionndi scta l neodant r hfa ec oef 24 thPee titthiPaoetnt itiinsoo entne tri ttofel deedrh aalb eas relcioerfp.u s Habeas 1 proceeadrtiehn pegr so pmeerc hanfoircs hma lletnhlgeei gnaoglr di utrya otfi on 2 confinewmheinalct ei rviiglah cttsii tsoh npe r opmeert htoocd h allceonngdeio tfi ons 3 confinemBeandvteC..ao x9,3F 1. 25d7 53,7(49 Ctih1r 9.9 P1e)t.i tifiovgnere oru'nsd s 4 forr elaipepfet aosr o lcehlayl ltehcneog ned iotfhi ioisnn sc arcbeyra astsieornt ing 5 clasiumcsah sc ruaenlud n uspuuanli shwmheepnnlt a icner de strfaaiinlttous r,e

6 protfreocmht a ramn,pd r isstoanhff asn'd olifhn imgsa i[lD.k Nto.1. ] T.h ose 7 challceonngceteshrc eno ndiotfhi iocsno sn fineamnemdnu tsb ter aiisnaec di vriilg hts 8 actuinodn4e 2rU .S§.1 C9.8 B3e.c aPuestei tdiooennsoea trp petaocr h alltehneg e 9 legaolrdi utrya otfhi iocsno nfinetmhePene tt,ifa tiiltososn t aact oeg nizable claim 10 federhaalb eraesl Fiuerft.h ermore,g rPoeufotnridr tsei lcoihneaeflr l'ceson ngdei tions 11o fh iisn carcbeyra astsieorvnta iganungecd o nclsutsaotreym Seen[etD skN.to .1., p p. 12 5-6(]a ssecrltaisinumgcsa h s" Retaliatciaounf/soiearmsc p tlaiigoeandi p nlsatif notriff 13 legsaulia tns"d"C rauneudln uspuuanli shbmyce onrtp aonrcdaa lp idteaplr ivation") 14 Tot heex tPeentti tiicsoh naelrl etnhcgeoi nndgi otfhi iocsno sn finetmheen t, 15 Couhratcs o nsiwdheertethdoce orn sPtertuiet iaolnleerga'asastc iiovrniisgl h ts

16 complSaeiHena tn.s voM.na y5,0 F2. 27d2 87,2(99 tChi1 r9.7 (4")D estphlieat bee ling 17 ofh icso mpl[atiphneett ,i twiaostn,he err]e efonrteit,toh l aevhdei a sc ttiroena atsae d 18 claimr efolurine dfte hrCe i vRiilg hts Act.P"e)t.i thHiaooaswnl eervree ard,y filed 19 twentyci-rvoiinglech otmsp lpauirnstusta o4n 2Ut . S§.1 C9.8i 3nt hCiosu rSteC.ea se 20 Nos1.8 -2P5S9G(5 A DS1)9;- 0P0S2G(2 A DS1)9;- 0P0S8G(5 A DS1)9;- 0P0S8G7 21 (ADS1)9;- 0P0S9G(3 A DS1)9;- 0P4S5G(4 A DS1)9;- 0P5S8G(7 A DS1)9;- 0P6S0G7 22 (ADS1)9;- 0P6S9G(9 A DS1)9;- 0P7S5G(0 A DS1)9;- 0P7S6G(8 A DS1)9;- 0P7S6G9 23 (ADS1)9;- 0P7S7G(4 A DS1)9;- 0P7S7G(6 A DS1)9;- 0P7S8G(2 A DS1)9;- 0P7S8G3 24 (ADS); P1S9G(- A0D7S8)6; P1S9G(- A0D7S19)91;- 1P1S4G9 (ADS); 19-01397 1 (ADS19)-;0 16P5S1G( ADST)h.o csoem plaalilnsetigsme ic llaarri emgsa rding 2 Petitiloengfiealrli' ansngm dse ditcraela tTmheenrte.ifo itrus en ,n ecetsocs oanrsyt rue 3 thceu rrfeednetrh aalb epaest iatsaic oinrv iiglch otmsp laint. 4 V. CONCLUSION

5 Petithiaofasni eltreos d t aact lea ciomg niuznadbfeeldree rhaalb eraesla inedf 6 hafisl emdu ltciiprvliiegl ah cttsia osnsset rhtesssa emc el aiImTIs ST. H EREFORE 7 ORDERtEhDta htai cst bieos nu mmarily wdiitshpmoriuestjs upedudir cseut aoRn utl e 8 4o ft hReu lGeosv erSneicnt2gi2 54oC na saensCd e ntDriaslto rfCi aclti foLronciaal 9 Rul7e2 -3J.u2d.g msehnabtle el n tered accordingly. 10 11 12 13 14

15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 CERTIFICATE OF APPEALABILITY 2 In addition, for reasons stated above, the Court finds that Petitioner has not 3 || shown that “jurists of reason would find it debatable whether:” (1) “the petition states a 4 || valid claim of the denial of a constitutional right;” and (2) “the district court was correct 5 ||in its procedural ruling.” See Slack v. McDaniel,

(2000). Thus, a 6 || certificate of appealability is denied. 7 ITISSO ORDERED. [Be 9 || Dated: nf; 96/5 — HONORABLE PHILIP S. GUTIERREZ 10 United States District Judge 11 12 || Presented by: 13 /s/ Autumn D. Spaeth HONORABLE AUTUMN D. SPAETH 14 || United States Magistrate Judge 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24