Keller v. Ybarru

California Supreme Court
Keller v. Ybarru, 3 Cal. 147 (Cal. 1853)
Heydenfeldt

Keller v. Ybarru

Opinion of the Court

Heydenfeldt, Justice,

delivered the opinion. Wells, Justice, concurred.

When the agreement, which is the subject of this action, was first entered into, it amounted to a mere offer on the part of the defendant, which the plaintiff had th,e right to accept or reject, and the defendant to retract, at any time before acceptance. When, however, the plaintiff named the amount of grapes which he would take under the offer of the defendant, the contract was complete, and both parties were bound by it.

The court below, therefore, erred in deciding for the defendant, and the judgment is reversed, with costs.

Reference

Full Case Name
M. KELLER v. R. YBARRU
Cited By
7 cases
Status
Published
Syllabus
A contract by defendant “ to deliver to plaintiff as many grapes as he should wish, at a given price,” is ajnbre offer, which the plaintiff had the right to accept or reject, and defendant to retract at any time before acceptance; but when the plaintiff named the quantity which he would take, the contract became complete, and both parties were bound by it.