Mellois v. Chaine
Mellois v. Chaine
Opinion of the Court
In this case, an agreed statement is presented for the purpose of obtaining the opinion of this Court as to the validity of the Foreign Miners’ License Tax. A simple statement of the agreed facts is before us, and no argument has been made, or brief filed on the part of the plaintiffs, who are the foreigners for whose benefit, obviously, the opinion is sought. This is not a suitable way of proceeding in such a case. If it is a serious question, it is one in which a large number of residents in this State are interested, and should be treated in a more serious manner.
In the absence of the requisite affidavit, the proceeding is one of which we cannot take cognizance, and the appeal is therefore dismissed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- MELLOIS v. CHAINE
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- Where an appeal is taken to the Supreme Court from a decision of a Justice’s Court, upon a case submitted on an agreed statement without action, under the three hundred and seventy-seventh section of the Practice Act, the transcript • on appeal must contain a copy of the affidavit required by the same section, showing the reality of the controversy and good faith of the proceeding. Where, instead of this affidavit, the record only showed an allegation in the agreed statement on appeal that the cause was heard in the Court below on an agreed statement of facts, “ and the affidavit of the defendant that the controversy was real,” the appeal was dismissed.