Truckee & Tahoe Turnpike Road Co. v. Campbell
Truckee & Tahoe Turnpike Road Co. v. Campbell
Opinion of the Court
It appears in this case, that the plaintiff is a corporation duly organized under the law providing for the formation of corporations, for the construction of plank and turnpike roads; that the Board of Supervisors of the County of Placer made and entered an order, authorizing the plaintiff to collect tolls from persons passing over a turnpike road leading from Tahoe City down and along Truckee River to a point near the mouth or outlet of Donner Creek, and fixed the rate of tolls; that the said turnpike road was then and still is under the management and control of the plaintiff; and that the defendant passed over the road with his team, and refused to pay the toll. The defendant moved for, and the Court granted, a nonsuit on the grounds that the evidence showed that the road was constructed prior to the organization of the corporation, and that a portion of the road had, prior to that time, been used by the public as a public and common highway.
The right to collect tolls on bridges, roads, etc., is a fran
Judgment reversed, and cause remanded for a new trial.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- THE TRUCKEE AND TAHOE TURNPIKE ROAD COMPANY v. J. B. CAMPBELL
- Cited By
- 15 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- Franchise.—The right to collect tolls on bridges, roads, etc., is a franchise. Idem.—Such a franchise is a certain privilege of a public nature, conferred by grant from the Government, and vested in individuals. It is a sovereign prerogative, and vests in an individual only by virtue of a legislative grant. Idem.—Whether granted directly by the Legislature, or by a subordinate body, to whom the power of granting it is delegated by legislative Act, the franchise is still a grant emanating from the sovereign authority of the State. Grant of Franchise by Board of Supervisors.—A grant of a turnpike franchise by a Board of Supervisors, made under authority granted by the Legislature, has the same standing in respect to its validity, the presumptions in its favor, and the mode in which it may be attacked, as a grant of any other right, privilege, or thing, made by any department of the Government under the authority of law. Franchise not to be Attacked by Private Person.—A grant of a turnpike franchise is not liable to be attacked by a private person, or in a collateral proceeding, for mere error in the exercise of the authority to make the grant.