Berry v. Cammet
Berry v. Cammet
Opinion of the Court
The sale of the lands of the State is committed to the executive department of the government; and the judicial department has no jurisdiction of controversies arising between applicants for the purchase of the lands, except in such matters as are expressly provided for by the statute. In order to give a Court jurisdiction of a controversy of that character, the facts conferring jurisdiction must be stated in the complaint. It is not enough that there are contesting claimants for the purchase of the same, lands, but the proceedings required by the statute before the Surveyor General and other officers concerned with the sale of the land must be had, and must be stated in the complaint.
It is provided by section twelve of the same Act, that whenever application is made for the purchase of lieu lands, the Surveyor General shall apply to the proper Land Office of the United States to have such lands accepted in part satisfaction of the grant under which it is sought to be located, and that when such acceptance shall have been obtained, he shall give to the applicant a certificate which shall authorize the proper County Treasurer to receive payment for the land. It requires no argument to show that it was not intended by the Act to authorize the sale of lieu lands until the selection by the State had been approved by the Register of the proper Land Office, nor to show that it was not intended that a contest should be brousht on to a hearino- before the Courts, to determine which party had the better right to purchase the lands from the State, before the State had taken the first step towards the acquisition of the title to the lands. The complaint fails to state that the Surveyor Gen
Judgment reversed and cause remanded, with directions to sustain the demurrer.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- A. W. BERRY v. JOHN CAMMET
- Cited By
- 4 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- Controversies Concerning Purchase of Lands.—The judicial department of the State has no jurisdiction of controversies arising between applicants for the purchase of State lands, except in cases where such jurisdiction is expressly conferred by statute. Complaint in Contest for Purchase of Lands.—When a controversy between applicants for the purchase of State lands is referred to the Courts for decision, the complaint in the action must state, not only that the parties are contesting claimants for the purchase of the land, but also all the facts conferring jurisdiction on the Court, such as the proceedings before the Surveyor General, and the order made by him referring it to the Courts. Sale of Lieu Lands.—Lieu lands cannot be sold by the State officers until the selection of them by the State has been approved by the Begister of the proper Land Office. Suit Concerning Bight to Buy Lieu Lands.—A suit concerning the right to purchase lieu lands cannot be commenced in the Courts until the Surveyor General has made an application to the Begister of the proper Land Office to have the land accepted in part satisfaction of the grant under which it is sought to locate them. Complaint in Suit Concerning Lieu Lands.—A complaint in an action between contesting applicants to buy lieu lands must aver that the Surveyor General has made application to the ¡Register to have the land accepted in part satisfaction of the grant under which it is sought to locate them.