People v. Ivey
People v. Ivey
Opinion of the Court
The evidence offered by the prisoner as to his good character having been permitted to go to the jury without objection, the Court, at the conclusion of the .argument, gave the following instruction: “The jury can consider evidence of the character of the accused only in relation to the particular crime charged in the indictment, and if none has been given upon this particular trait the jury are not at liberty to consider evidence in respect to other traits of
Judgment and order reversed, and cause remanded for a new trial.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- THE PEOPLE v. JOHN IVEY
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- Jury Cannot Decide on the Law.—The Court cannot submit to the determination of the jury a question of mere law. Pertinency of Evidence not to be Submitted to Jury.—The Court must nqt submit evidence to the jury hypothetically, that is to say, to be considered by them if they are of the opinion that it is applicable to the issue, but to be disregarded by them if they are of a contrary opinion. Jury Cannot Decide on Pertinency op Evidence.—It will not do to admit improper evidence, and then leave the question of its pertinency to the jury.