Ex Parte White
Ex Parte White
Opinion of the Court
The petitioner has been brought before us on a writ of habeas corpus, and it appears from the return of the Chief of Police, that he is held under a warrant of arrest issued by a magistrate having authority to issue such writs. It further appears that there was presented to the magistrate, before and at the time of issuing the warrant, an affidavit made in this State, to the effect that the petitioner had committed the crime of grand larceny in the commonwealth of Massachusetts, and is a fugitive from justice from that State. But it was not shown, by the affidavit or otherwise, that a prosecution is pending, or has ever been instituted in Massachusetts against the petitioner for the alleged offense.
Section 1,548 of the Penal Code, provides that “ a person charged in any State of the United States, with treason, felony, or other crime, who flees from justice, and is found in this State, must, on demand of the. executive authority of the State from which he fled,” be delivered up by the Governor of this State. Under this section, it is evident the Governor has no authority to surrender a fugitive, unless he has been “ charged ” with crime in the State from which he fled. A prosecution must have been intimated there, before the Governor can act. Section 1,549 provides that “ a magistrate may issue a warrant for the apprehension of a person so charged, who flees from justice and is found in this State;” and the seven next succeeding sections provide what steps shall be taken for the detention of the fugitive until a requisition shall be made for his surrender by the proper authorities of the State from which he fled.
The first point for consideration is, whether this case comes within the purview of the statute, and we are convinced it does not. It was not intended that a person might be arrested here upon an affidavit or information
Ordered that the prisoner be discharged from custody.
Mr. Chief Justice Wallace and Mr. Justice McKinstry concurred specially in the judgment.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Ex Parte JOHN WHITE
- Cited By
- 6 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- Fugitives prom Justice.—The Governor of this State has no authority to surrender a fugitive who has committed a crime in another State, unless judicial proceedings have been commenced against him for the crime in the State in which it was committed. Arrest op Fugitives prom Justice.—A person cannot he arrested here for a crime committed in another State, unless a prosecution has been commenced, and is pending against him for the alleged crime in the State having jurisdiction of the offense. Constitutionality op Law Concerning Fugitives prom Justice.—The Court say, without passing authoritatively on the point, that no reason is perceived why a law allowing fugitives from justice fleeing from another State to be arrested here and delivered up to the authorities of the State having jurisdiction of the offense, is not constitutional.