McLean v. Blue Point Gravel Mining Co.
McLean v. Blue Point Gravel Mining Co.
Opinion of the Court
Section 1970 of the Civil Code (which “ establishes the law of this State respecting the subjects to which it relates,” —Id. Sec. 4.) provides as follows:
“ Sec. 1970. An employer is not bound to indemnify his employee for losses suffered by the latter in consequence of the ordinary risk of the business in which he is employed, nor in consequence of the negligence of another person employed by the same employer in the same general business, unless he .has neglected to use ordinary care in the selection of the- culpable employee.”
The injury to the plaintiff was caused by the negligence of Regan, the foreman of defendant, who was a fellow-servant with the plaintiff—“another person employed by the same employer in the same general business,” that is, the business of working the mine of the defendant—Regan being in the blasting, and the plaintiff in the hydraulic department of the ‘ ‘generalbusiness.” The section of the Civil Code already recited declares that to such,a case the rule of respondeat superior shall not apply, unless there has been want of ordinary care upon the part of the defendant in the selection
Order affirmed,
Reference
- Full Case Name
- ALEXANDER McLEAN v. THE BLUE POINT GRAVEL MINING COMPANY
- Cited By
- 11 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- Liability op Employer to Employee,—An employer is not bound, to in- . demnify an employee for damages he sustains in consequence of the negligence of a fellow-employee employed by the same employer in the same general business. Idem.—The above rule is not changed by the fact that the employee through whose negligence the injury came was the superior of the employee who was injured, in the service in which they were engaged.