California Supreme Court, 1877

Pickard v. Kelley

Pickard v. Kelley
California Supreme Court · Decided July 1, 1877
52 Cal. 89

Pickard v. Kelley

Opinion of the Court

To maintain an action of forcible entry there must be an actual and peaceable possession in the plaintiff. ( Vall v. Butler, 49 Cal. 75 ; sec. 1172, Code Civil Procedure.)

The certificate of pre-emption would not even give a right of possession, and certainly would not prove the fact of possession.

A deed is not admissible in evidence to show possession, or to show a right of possession. (Sanchez v. Louregro, 46 Cal. 641.),

*90J. W- Hendrick, for the Eespondent.

By the Court :

The “ certificate of pre-emption ” did not tend to show actual possession in the plaintiff, and the Court below erred in admitting it in evidence.

Judgment and order reversed, and calase remanded for a new trial.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.