California Supreme Court, 1877

McGuire v. Quintana

McGuire v. Quintana
California Supreme Court · Decided July 1, 1877
52 Cal. 427

McGuire v. Quintana

Opinion of the Court

The offered evidence should have been received. It tended to show that nothing was due to the contractor, the Bridge Company. (Pomroy’s Rem. Rights, sec. 700; Frisch v. Caler, 21 Cal. 71; Fairchild v. Amshaugh, 22 Cal. 575.)

*428Harrison & McMu/rtry, for the Respondent.

A breach of contract and damages under it must be specially pleaded. (Blethen v. Blalce, 44 Cal. 117; Piercy v. ¿Sabin, 10 Cal. 22; Philips on Mechanics’ Liens, sec. 424.)

By the Court :

The answer of the defendant was a general denial—nothing more. It was not competent for him to prove, under an answer of that character, “ that the buildings- were not finished by the contractor according to the contract,” etc. (Blethen v. Blake, 44 Cal. 117.)

Judgment affirmed. Remittitur forthwith.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.