Pulliam v. Cherokee Flat Blue Gravel Co.
California Supreme Court
Pulliam v. Cherokee Flat Blue Gravel Co., 52 Cal. 605 (Cal. 1878)
Pulliam v. Cherokee Flat Blue Gravel Co.
Opinion of the Court
The corporation defendant was permitted, against the objection of plaintiff, to prove that it had made an application at the United States Land Office to obtain the title to the premises in controversy. The avowed purpose of this proof was to show . that the defendant had exercised control and dominion over the premises. But the circumstance that such an application has been filed in the Land Office did not tend, even in the remotest degree, to show the exercise by the applicant of control over the premises.
Judgment and order denying a new trial reversed, and cause remanded for a new trial.
Remittitur forthwith.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- M. R. C. PULLIAM v. CHEROKEE FLAT BLUE GRAVEL COMPANY
- Cited By
- 2 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- Evidence—Dominion and Control.— The fact that a party has made application to the United States Land Office to obtain title to certain premises does not tend, even in the most remote degree, to show that such party ever had or exercised dominion and control over the premises.