People v. Coch

California Supreme Court
People v. Coch, 53 Cal. 627 (Cal. 1879)
1879 Cal. LEXIS 67

People v. Coch

Opinion of the Court

By the Court :

The defendant was indicted for the crime of arson. The Court instructed the jury that if they found the defendant guilty the form of their verdict should be: “ We, the jury in the above cause, find the defendant guilty as charged in the indictment.”

Arson is divided into two degrees. (Penal Code, secs. 453, 454.) It is provided by the Penal Code, sec. 1157, that “ whenever a crime is distinguished into degrees, the jury, if they convict the defendant, must find the degree of the crime of which he is guilty.” The instruction was erroneous.

Judgment and order reversed, and cause remanded for a new trial.

Reference

Full Case Name
THE PEOPLE v. COCH
Cited By
4 cases
Status
Published
Syllabus
Arson—Juby must bind Degree of Crime.—On the trial of a defendant for arson, if the jury find him guilty, it is their duty to find the degree of the crime of which he is guilty; and it is error for the Court to instruct them that if they find him guilty they should return as their verdict that they find him “ guilty as charged in the indictment.”