Cal. Southern R. R. v. Kimball
Cal. Southern R. R. v. Kimball
Opinion of the Court
Conceding that none of the public streets of San Diego can be used by a railroad company, unless the right to use the same is granted by the city, in the manner prescribed by law, it does not seem to us to follow, that an action to condemn whatever right the owners of lands lying adjacent to said streets may have therein can not be maintained until after said city has granted a right of way over said streets.
If, as the appellants contend, the streets can not be used by the plaintiff until after it has acquired the right to use them from the city, as well as from the owners of adjacent lands, we are unable to see why the grant from the city should be first obtained. The lands of appellants cannot be taken until paid for, and then for no other purpose than that designated in the complaint. If a grant by the city authority is essential to the right to use the streets for railroad purposes, it can make no difference to the appellants whether such grant is or is not obtained by the plaintiff.
We do not think that Section 1249, C. C. P., which provides that for the purpose of assessing compensation and damages in cases like this the right thereto shall be deemed to have accrued at the date of the summons, is inconsistent, with Section 14 of Article i. of the present Constitution of this State. The value of the property at some period antedating the judgment could alone be awarded to the owner, because the award
We are satisfied that the findings and judgment are in accordance with the requirements of the Code.
Judgment affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- CAL. SOUTHERN R. R. v. FRANK A. KIMBALL
- Cited By
- 22 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- Eminent Domain—Railroad—City.—In a proceeding to condemn land including certain streets in the City of San Diego for the use of the plaintiff’s railroad, it was objected on demurrer that the complaint did not allege that the authorities of the city had granted plaintiff the right to use the streets in question. Held : The demurrer was properly overruled. Id.—Id.—Id.—Conceding that the streets of a city can not be used by a railroad company until the right to use the same has been granted by the city as prescribed in § 470 of the Civil Code it is not necessary that such grant shall first be obtained in order to maintain an action to condemn the rights of adjacent land owners in such streets. Id.—Value op Property—Constitutional Law.—Section 1249 C. C. P.— which provides that, for the purpose of assessing compensation and damages in cases like this, the right thereto shall he deemed to have accrued at the date of the summons—is not inconsistent with § 14 of Article i. of the Constitution.