Robinson v. Irish-American Benevolent Society
Robinson v. Irish-American Benevolent Society
Opinion of the Court
The defendant is a benevolent corporation organized under the laws of the State, its object in part being the relieving and assisting of its sick members. The plaintiff became a member in 1869, and has since been a member thereof in good standing and entitled to all its benefits. The constitution governing the corporation provides for the election of a physician, whose duty it is to attend the sick members, and among other things, “ to give a certificate of bad health when applied to and the case
It appears from the record that on the 3d of October, 1881, the plaintiff demanded of the society payment to him of $352,' which he claimed to be due him as sick allowance, accruing subsequent to November 29,1880. The claim was presented to the society at its regular monthly meeting, which was held the even- ■ ing of the day of the demand, and was by the society referred to its board of trustees. Instead of awaiting the consideration and determination of the board, the plaintiff within a few days commenced this suit against the society to recover the amount claimed by him. He undoubtedly did so, as appears from the record, because the physician at the instance of one of the trustees had some time before ceased furnishing the plaintiff with a certificate of his illness. It clearly appears from the evidence that plaint-" iff was sick and unable to work during' the time for which he claimed the allowance, and had been so circumstanced for a long, time prior thereto. But it is not to be presumed that the board of trustees would, upon the facts being made to appear, have, refused to award the plaintiff the relief to which he was entitled. • At all events, the plaintiff, when he became a member of the
Judgment and order reversed.
McKee, J., and McKinstry, J. concurred.
Hearing in Bank denied
Reference
- Full Case Name
- MICHAEL ROBINSON v. THE IRISH-AMERICAN BENEVOLENT SOCIETY
- Cited By
- 5 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- Benevolent Corporation—Constitution and By-laws—Assent to Bind Membebs. —A member of a benevolent corporation who has assented to the provisions of its constitution and by-laws is bound by them. Id.—Allowance to Sick Members—Action to Recover.—The constitution of the corporation provided that members when sick, upon complying with certain conditions, should be entitled to an allowance out of tho funds of the corporation; that the board of trustees should examine all claims of members for such allowance, and that no money should be paid out of the corporate funds except upon the order of the trustees. Held, that a member could not maintain an action to recover the allowance until after the board of trustees had been given an opportunity to examine his claim therefor.