May v. Steele

California Supreme Court
May v. Steele, 2 Cal. Unrep. 611 (Cal. 1885)
9 P. 112

May v. Steele

Opinion of the Court

By the COURT.

Appeal from a judgment and order denying a new trial in an action to recover damages for personal injuries. Two assignments of error are made in the case: (1) That the verdict is not justified by the evidence; (2) that the damages awarded are excessive.

As to the first, there was a substantial conflict in the evidence. The verdict must therefore be taken as conclusive of the facts.

As to the second, we cannot say, as matter of law, that the verdict was given under the influences of passion, prejudice, or bias of any kind.

Judgment and order affirmed.

Reference

Full Case Name
MAY and Others v. STEELE
Status
Published
Syllabus
Assault and Battery—Excessive Damages.—In an action for damages caused by a beating, a verdict of thirteen hundred dollars will not be set aside as excessive.