In Re Estate of Rounds
In Re Estate of Rounds
Opinion of the Court
This is an appeal by certain nieces and nephews of Sarah C. Rounds from an order refusing to make a partial distribution to them of the assets of her estate by reason of the fact that they are heirs, respectively, of her sister, Mary E. Barbour, and her brother, Hiram Edwards.
Mrs. Rounds died testate. She left certain legacies to charity and to nephews and nieces, and her will contained the following provision: “To each of my sisters and brother living five hundred ($500) dollars. ’ ’ At the time the will was executed she had two sisters and a brother living. Two of them, Hiram A. Edwards and Mrs. Mary E. Barbour, predeceased the testatrix. Appellants here, who are the sons and daughters of the deceased sister and brother of Mrs. Rounds, are, under section 1310 of the Civil Code, as they assert, entitled to take, as descendants, their proportions of the legacies of these predeceased beneficiaries under the will of Mrs. Rounds.
The whole question presented to this court turns upon the interpretation of the word “living” as used in the will.
“To each of my brothers and sisters living two hundred. ($200.00) dollars. Their names Mrs. Mary M. Barber, Mrs. Helen Augusta McOmber, William J. Edwards and Hiram A. Edwards.”
After the preparation of this rough draft William Edwards died and his sister then drew a pencil line through his name. Mrs. Rounds then told Mrs. Rodgers that she had one brother and two sisters who were still alive, and that she wanted provision made for them to the extent of five hundred dollars each. Mrs. Rodgers then wrote the clause of the will which is here in dispute, and she testified: “I do not think that Mrs. Rounds suggested the use of the word ‘living’ in this connection. ’ ’
The order from which this appeal is taken is affirmed.
Lennon, J., and Wilbur, J. concurred
Reference
- Full Case Name
- In the Matter of the Estate of SARAH C. ROUNDS, Deceased
- Cited By
- 6 cases
- Status
- Published