Edwards v. Smith
Cases that cite this one
21 later published cases cite this decision.
- Lamon v. Zamp (Colo. 1927)
- LeDoux v. Horowitz (Colo. 1921)
- Whipple v. Wessels (Colo. 1919)
- Campbell v. Weller (Wyo. 1917)
- Tate v. Holly (Colo. App. 1914)
- Tate v. Holly (Colo. App. 1914)
- County of Washington v. Murray (Colo. 1909)
- Beals v. Cone (Colo. 1900)
- Supreme Lodge, Knights of Honor v. Davis (Colo. 1899)
- Denver, Texas & Fort Worth Railroad v. Pulaski Irrigating Ditch Co. (Colo. App. 1898)
- Denver, Texas & Fort Worth Railroad v. Pulaski Irrigating Ditch Co. (Colo. App. 1898)
- Willard v. Williams (Colo. App. 1897)
- Willard v. Williams (Colo. App. 1897)
- Christ v. Flannagan (Colo. 1896)
- Ritchey v. People (Colo. 1896)
- Holman v. Boston Land & Security Co. (Colo. App. 1896)
- Holman v. Boston Land & Security Co. (Colo. App. 1896)
- People v. Berlin (Utah 1894)
- People v. Hart (Utah 1894)
- Jacobs v. Mitchell (Colo. App. 1892)
- Jacobs v. Mitchell (Colo. App. 1892)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
It is contended by counsel for appellant that the action is one of equitable cognizance, and so not within the juris
Whether the objection to the jurisdiction of the district court might have been maintained if it had been insisted on in apt time without waiver, we need not consider. There being no necessity for written pleadings in cases originating before justices of the peace, the question whether the justice has jurisdiction in a particular case must ordinarily be determined from the evidence. In this case, however, we regard the stipulation entered into between the parties as decisive of the jurisdictional question.
After the cause had reached the county court the parties . entered into a stipulation in writing, making it a part of the record, to the effect that the cause should be removed into the district court, and that certain specified matters and differences between them should be there tried. The parties appeared in the district court, and went to trial in pursuance of such stipulation. Having thus voluntarily submitted their controversy to a court having jurisdiction of the subject-matter thereof, they cannot afterwards be heard to question the authority of such tribunal. This is no violation of the principle that consent cannot confer jurisdiction over the subject-matter of a cause. The constitutional jurisdiction of the district court extends to “ all causes, both at law and in equity.” It was competent for the parties by stipulation to waive any objection they might have to the trial of the cause by the county court on appeal, or by the district court on change of venue, and to voluntarily submit their matters of difference to trial by the district court, which they did. Lyon v. Washburn, 3 Colo. 201; Behymer v. Nordloh, 12 Colo. 352, and cases there cited.
The court charged and instructed the jury orally by consent. It does not appear that any specific objections were made to any part of the charge. At the close of the charge,
This disposes of the assignments of error so far as they are properly presented by the abstract and brief of appellant. The case has been twice tried, first by the justice of the peace, and-second by a jury in the district court, with substantially the same result at each trial. FTo substantial errors have been made apparent on this appeal. The judgment of the district court is affirmed.
Affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.