Greene v. Gibson
Cases that cite this one
1 later published case cites this decision.
- Hanshue v. Marvin Investment Co. (Colo. 1919)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court;
As the judgment must be reversed for the reason that the court erroneously excluded evidence offered on the part of defendant, it is unnecessary to pass upon the question raised by the motion to dismiss; as at another trial evidence can, in all probability, be adduced which will eliminate this question.
The defendant offered in evidence the judgment roll in an action brought in the county court of Yuma county by the party under whom he deraigned title, to quiet title to the premises involved, which was objected to, and the objection3 sustained, for the reason that it appeared the court did not have jurisdiction of either the subject matter of controversy, or of certain of the defendants. This ruling was erroneous. Section 1055, Mills’ Stats., provides, that in order to give the county courts of this state jurisdiction in any action, suit or proceeding, the plaintiff shall state that the value of the property in controversy, or the amount involved for’which relief is sought, does not exceed the sum of two thousand dollars. Under this section it has been frequently ruled, that the jurisdiction of a county court being limited by statute, it must affirmatively appear by the complaint that the case brought in such tribunal is within the jurisdiction of the court. — Learned v. Tritch, 6 Colo. 432; Home v. Duff, 5 Colo. 574.
There is nothing, however, in the section to which we have referred, that indicates an intention to require the juris
■ Certain of the defendants in the action in the county court were served by publication. The affidavit upon which the order for this service was made stated that these parties “either reside out of the state of. Colorado, or have departed therefrom without intention of ■ returning, or concéal themselves to avoid the service of process; and that said defendants and 'each and every of them cannot, after -due diligence, be found within the state of Colorado.” The affiant then states facts ■ from which it appears that he had exercised due diligence to ascertain the whereabouts and postoffice addresses of-these parties; that he was unable to'do so, and that their postoffice addresses were unknown to. him. The objection urged to the affidavit is, that as the code (sec.-41, Mills’) provides that service may be made by publication when it appears by proper affidavit that-“the defendant resides out of the
The defendant offered in evidence a tax deed for the premises involved, which, from the argument of counsel, we assume was excluded for two- reasons : (i) That it appealed therefrom the requisite notice.of sale had not been-given,; and (2) that the certificate of sale upon which it was based had not been properly assigned to the grantee named in the deed. We do not deem it necessary to- pass upon either of -these questions. The judgment rendered in the action to quiet title, brought in the county court, established title in the defendant superior to that of the plaintiff, and as at present advised .from the record, was entitled to judgment accordingly, independent of'the validity of the tax deed.
Reversed md Remanded.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.