Middleton v. McCarthy Hidden Treasure Mining Corp.
Middleton v. McCarthy Hidden Treasure Mining Corp.
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
The plaintiff in error, as assignee of The Giant Powder Company, brought suit in replevin against The McCarthy
It appears that plaintiff in error, as agent of The Giant Powder Company, in August, 1917, sold to The Hidden Treasure Mines Company the powder in question, which was delivered to said company about the middle of September following. Thereupon the said Mines Company gave a chattel mortgage upon said powder to one Whinnery to secure a note of $5,000, executed contemporaneously with the mortgage, which note evidenced an indebtedness of some hundred dollars to, Whinnery, and was, in addition, to secure him for advances which he had agreed to make.
It appears from the undisputed testimony that shortly after the giving of said mortgage, the bond and lease, under which the said Mines Company was working mining property in Lake County, Colorado, was forfeited, and soon thereafter defendant in error, The McCarthy Hidden Treasure Mining Corporation was organized to work the same property. It secured from Whinnery an assignment of the note and chattel mortgage upon an agreement with him that it would pay him what the Mines Company owed him, and would carry out his agreement with said company to pay certain overdue labor bills contracted by that company. The McCarthy Company took possession of the powder, and paid the Whinnery debt and the labor bills, amounting in all to something over $6,000.
It appears from the undisputed testimony that when the plaintiff in error discovered what he now says was a fraudulent representation, he took no steps to disaffirm the sale, but on the other hand demanded payment from the manager of the Mines Company, and was assured by him that payment for the powder would be made in a short time. After
Mr. Justice Scott and Mr. Justice Bailey not participating.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Middleton v. The McCarthy Hidden Treasure Mining Corporation
- Status
- Published