Clark v. Gregg, Whitehead & Co.
Clark v. Gregg, Whitehead & Co.
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
The defendants in error, a copartnership, brought an action against the plaintiff in error, and three others, upon a promissory note executed by the plaintiff in error, and had judgment. The cause is before us on error.
The complaint charged that the four defendants purchased from the plaintiff 2,000 shares of the capital stock of The Lusk Royalty Company, and as part payment therefor, caused defendant Clark “as trustee for all of said defendants to, and said Paul M. Clark did, make, execute and deliver to plaintiff a promissory note” etc. The note is attached as an exhibit and made a part of the complaint. It is in the usual form of a collateral note, and recites that the maker had deposited with the payee 2,000 shares of The Lusk Royalty Company stock. The note was signed by Clark “trustee.” The prayer of the complaint is for judgment “against the defendants and each of them.” Defendants Loehwing and Ickes filed a joint demurrer. The demurrer was sustained, and the action dismissed as to them. Clark, after the overruling of his demurrer to the complaint, answered and a demurrer to the answer was sustained. He thereupon filed an amended answer in which he set up that the note was given by him as trustee, for all the defendants, and that the trust included the holding of the title to said stock, that it. was understood and agreed
It is assigned as error that the action was dismissed as to the two defendants named. Clark’s answer alleged the facts, setting out in detail what was alleged , in the complaint, and which, if established, would show that the plaintiffs are not entitled to a judgment against Clark alone. The court erred in dismissing the action as to two defend
The judgment is accordingly reversed and remanded with instructions for further proceedings in harmony with the views herein expressed.
Mr. Justice Allen and Mr. Justice Burke concur.
Reference
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published