Rosoff v. Gilbert Transp. Co.
Cases that cite this one
3 later published cases cite this decision.
- Business Advisory Bureau, Inc. v. Stallforth (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1941)
- Carpenter v. Griffith Mortgage Corp. (Court of Chancery of Delaware 1934)
- In re Canister Co. (District Court, D. New Jersey 1918)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
I regret to take any course which will cause any further delay in this case, already too protracted. But it is entirely clear, in my opinion, that the practice pursued in this matter of suing for the full amount due on stock subscriptions, without a preliminary assessment, was unauthorized. In the case of a solvent corporation, while a going concern, the directors, in their discretion, can call in all amounts unpaid on stock subscriptions; but in the case of a bankrupt corporation the trustee can only sue the stockholders for such amounts as have been determined by a preliminary investiga! ion and assessment to be necessary to pay the debts and expenses. Scovill v. Thayer, 105 U. S. 143, 26 L. Ed. 968; Re Remington Co., 153 Fed. 345, 82 C. C. A. 421; Re Munger Co., 168 Fed. 910, 94 C. C. A. 314; Cumberland Lumber Co. v. Clinton Hill Lumber Manufacturing Co., 57 N. J. Eq. 627, 42 Atl. 585; Lewisohn v. Stoddard, 78 Conn. 575, 63 Atl. 621. When the debts unquestionably exceed the amount of unpaid subscriptions, possibly a preliminary assessment is unnecessary. But it is at least doubtful in this case whether the valid debts are sufficient to require a call for the entire unpaid subscriptions.
The claim of the bondholders that they are creditors to the amount
I think that the question whether any stockholder can be assessed who has purchased, for value, without notice, stock issued as full-paid and nonassessable should be determined in. the pending suits, and not on the reference. In re Munger & Co., 168 Fed. 910, 94 C. C. A. 314. It would seem that all the questions raised by the intervening bill will be determined either in the reference or the pending suits, and that the bill might be dropped; but if the interveners desire to go on with it, I will consider on the settlement of the order whether to direct the bondholders and the American Surety Company to answer.
The order should be settled on notice.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.