United States ex rel. Bambini v. Martineau
United States ex rel. Bambini v. Martineau
Opinion of the Court
This matter is now before the Court on the petition of Romano Bambini for a writ of habeas corpus in order to test the validity of an order of deportation issued against him by the Department of Labor.
Petitioner was arrested under a Labor Warrant o„f Arrest which was issued on October 14th, 1936, and charged him with violating Title 8, Sec. 155 of the U.S.C., 8
The evidence upon which these findings were made are sufficiently substantial to warrant and support the same. The only question raised upon this petition for habeas corpus is whether or not the alien was accorded a “fair hearing.” The fairness of this hearing is attacked upon the ground that ex parte evidence, by way of affidavits, was received and considered by the Department of Labor in arriving at its findings of fact.
It appears that no objection was made to the introduction of this evidence, nor did the alien, either in person or through his counsel, request the opportunity of cross-examining the affiants upon these affidavits. The rule is well settled that, under such conditions, the fairness of the hearing may not be impeached because of the reception of such evidence. See U. S. ex rel. Diamond v. Uhl, 2 Cir., 266 F. 34; Imazo Itow v. Nagle, 9 Cir., 24 F.2d 526; Healy v. Backus, 9 Cir., 221 F. 358.
I am therefore constrained to hold that the alien received a fair hearing, and that the warrant of deportation issued against him is valid. The writ is dismissed, and the relator is remanded to the custody which produced him. Submit order accordingly properly consented to as to form.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- UNITED STATES ex rel. BAMBINI v. MARTINEAU, Divisional Director of Immigration and Naturalization
- Status
- Published