Gervais v. Fred Brunoli Sons, No. Cv99-0270225s (Dec. 1, 2000)
Opinion of the Court
The complaint in this case alleges that the plaintiff, an electrician, was working in the vicinity of a suspension ceiling ("ceiling") constructed by the defendant Thermal Fireproofing and Acoustics Company ("Thermal") which gave way, causing the plaintiff to fall and suffer personal injuries. The complaint further alleges that Thermal, as a product seller under §
DISCUSSION
A party who contracts only for the provision of services is not a product seller for purposes of CPLA; whether a particular contract is one solely for the provision of services depends on the language of the contract and on the manner in which the contract is performed. Paul v.McPhee Electrical Contractors,
In support of its motion, Thermal has submitted a copy of the contract ("contract") by which it undertook to construct the ceiling, the relevant portion of which states:
"The Subcontractor agrees to furnish all labor, materials (sic) equipment, etc (sic) necessary to perform the work required for the completion of all work specified in Sections 2070 Demolition (Removal of existing ceilings), 9510 Acousticall Ceilings 09520 Acoustical Wall Panel:
(A) Pelz Gymnasium — Removal of Existing Ceilings approximately 12,000/sf of existing ceilings and installation of new ceilings per plans specifications."
In the absence of other materials relating to the contents or performance of the contract, the court cannot determine, as a matter of law, whether Thermal was a product seller.
CONCLUSION
The motion is denied.
Levine, J.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.