This action arose out of the same automobile collision as that dealt with in the preceding case of Peter H. Brown against the same defendants. The two cases were tried together, and identical questions were raised on each appeal.

For the reasons stated in Peter EL Brown v. Howard J. Wright et ais., ante, p. 193, there is error, the judgment is set aside and new trial ordered as to William J. Donovan. There is no error as to Julia Shea and Dennis Donovan.